Mini-Review: For me, this is the best Scorsese since Kundun. Actually, it's his only film I liked since Kundun. But I have to say that it was totally predictable, even before I got in the theatre. And the ending wasn't really satisfying.
| 58 |
 |
Nine - Mar 02, 2010 |
Mini-Review: The only real movie moment comes at the test screening with Cotillard, the only real good song (and performance) is "Take It All"... So, I think it's safe to say that Marion Cotillard is the best thing in this film... Kate Hudson's character is totally useless. A bit more focus on the relationship between Day-Lewis and Cotillard instead could've actually make this film work.
| 43 |
 |
Veda - Mar 01, 2010 |
Mini-Review: extremely well crafted film with the most powerful and thought provoking finale of the year. and that finale should easily bring this film the oscar.
Mini-Review: Surprisingly close to the ways of classic horror literature, but still uninteresting and cliché-driven. I'm pretty sure that the CGI supported make-up job won't be nominated for an Oscar next year. Elfman's score had some moments of clear reference to Wojciech Kilar's Dracula score. But in the end, it's really Emily Blunt who saves this from being a complete waste of time.
Mini-Review: Great material, but in-your-face attitude and repetetive, lazy narrative doesn't match.