login | register
0 film rankings
more

Ida ()

Probable Score
Not Enough Info
Your Rating

Acclaimed director Pawel Pawlikowski (Last Resort, My Summer of Love) returns to his homeland for this moving and intimate drama about a young novitiate nun in 1960s Poland who, on the verge of taking her vows, discovers a dark family secret dating from the terrible years of the Nazi occupation. (tiff.net)

RatingsRatings
FindFind
CollectionsCollections
StatsStats
loading Loading Products from Ebay
Loading...
loading
Ida belongs to 70 collections
1. 1001 Movies You Must See Before You Die (public: moderated by kozan26 - 182 stars)
2. 21st Century Top 250 (public: moderated by dardan - 38 stars)
3. Oscar: Best Foreign Film (public: moderated by PeaceAnarchy - 24 stars)
4. Post-1960s black & white photography (public: moderated by djross - 18 stars)
5. Edgar Wright 1000 Favorite Movies (Aug 2016) (public: moderated by Aron Ericson - 8 stars)
6. European Film Awards: Best Film (public: moderated by CCLZA - 7 stars)
7. Best Foreign Film Oscar Nominees (public: moderated by snallygaster - 7 stars)
8. 1960s period film (public: moderated by djross - 4 stars)
10. European Film Awards: Best Film (nominations) (public: moderated by Rubens - 4 stars)
11. Nuns (public: moderated by Moribunny - 3 stars)
12. Toronto International Film Festival 2013 (public: moderated by toro913 - 1 star)
14. BBC's The 21st Century's 100 Greatest Films (public: moderated by jeff_h - 1 star)
15. FThisMovie JB's Top 10 (public: moderated by djcrawfo)
16. 2014 US Theatrical (public: moderated by DrBroel)
17. film puanlamalarım (public: moderated by sacidu)
18. Djross overrated movies (private: djross - 4 stars)
19. 87th Academy Awards: Nominated (private: okayfrog - 3 stars)
20. explorer nflix queue (private: explorer - 1 star)
21. AFK 2014 (your private collection - 1 star) | remove from collection
22. Next Next 10 (private: kendell - 1 star)
23. Djross PSI was way off (private: djross)
24. To see (private: pcalado)
25. Ignored Films (your private collection) | remove from collection
26. Curzon Ripon (private: mandy)
27. 2014 Seen in theaters (private: fartblaster)
28. Sundance 2014 - Spotlight (private: chemical404)
29. Criticker Wishlist (your private collection) | remove from collection
31. K&A (private: caffe)
32. 2014 (private: krulltott)
33. flogged's 1001 (private: smuhu)
34. Most Loved of 2014 (your private collection) | remove from collection
35. 2014 Foreign Movies (private: NhanLa)
36. Foreign - Polish (private: NhanLa)
38. Edgar Wright's 1000 Favorite Movies (private: coldesser)
39. Edgar 256 (private: caffe)
40. KENDELL'S MASSIVE LIST (private: kendell)
41. ForeignOscar++ (private: jormungand)
42. Criticker Wishlist (your private collection) | remove from collection
43. Ayıla Bayıla İzlenen Filmler (private: Giskard)
44. Unconventional Cinema (private: holsgr)
Browse the full list of collections
Show:
All Rankings | With Reviews
Order by:
TCI | Percentile | Date Ranked | # Stars (Reviews)
Date User Score
May 22 Icarusion Icarusion
55 35%
May 21 imtheren imtheren
8 80%
May 21 mmb888
75 32%
May 21 flowing flowing
72 82%
May 18 gunay
84 16%
May 14 themattknarr
95 98%
May 13 poeticfilm
75 46%
May 13 muutanet muutanet
67 60%
A beautiful cinematography did not save a weak story.
May 12 otluke otluke
74 57%
May 09 summerbag
90 79%
May 08 brennanc
8 65%
May 08 normatic normatic
80 82%
May 07 Fuck Fuck
9 94%
May 07 Siegel Hans
80 83%
May 05 Grandaddy
70 60%
May 03 marla-singer
98 75%
May 03 dragos
70 57%
May 03 arashfo arash.fo
60 9%
May 02 afireinside
95 94%
May 02 coklas92
30 9%
May 01 John Milton
80 87%
Apr 29 q.fincher
70 64%
Apr 28 energ1s
90 74%
Apr 26 lifeasadog lifeasadog
70 53%
Apr 23 Vegdrib
80 75%
Apr 22 chone
80 75%
Apr 22 eppursimuove
75 41%
Apr 21 hitagi
90 75%
Apr 20 zljk
82 94%
Apr 19 fictionfitz
81 82%
Apr 16 suleymnpeter
75 52%
Apr 14 lucylarssonx lucylarssonx
40 15%
Apr 13 dourface dourface
80 86%
Apr 10 mate_cosido
90 89%
Apr 04 deniz.genc
65 27%
Apr 01 Djaba
93 72%
Apr 01 gozdebal gozdebal
80 79%
Mar 30 aeginalethe aeginalethe
90 93%
Mar 30 FlixMG7 FlixMG7
80 85%
Mar 28 horrorjames
30 19%
Mar 25 mkdaun
80 76%
Mar 25 alfieg
90 91%
Mar 25 nihilcthulhu nihilcthulhu
70 50%
Mar 25 Recker
40 15%
Mar 23 rieux
72 53%
Mar 12 OnlyMovies
80 76%
Mar 09 scottmcc scott.mcc
80 86%
Mar 02 trueiceman
62 37%
Feb 24 iyisinek iyisinek
70 42%
Polonya, Rahibe, geçmiş, teyze, soykırım, yahudi, (Rahibe olan ve yeminine az süre kalan İda'nın teyzesi ile görüşmesi gerekir. Teyzesinden hikayesini öğrenen İda, teyzesi ile hikayesinin peşinden gider. SP Ailesi soykırım sırasında öldürülmüştür ve İda aslen Yahudidir. Evlerinde şimdi başkaları yaşamaktadır. Teyzesi ile İda ailesinin mezarını aramaya koyulur. SP AĞIR, hikaye yavaş ilerliyor ama izlenebilir. Siyah Beyaz
Feb 23 cenk_k cenk k.
83 81%
Feb 23 bsgb
78 79%
Feb 18 DiegoL_ii Diego_L
86 91%
Feb 18 oktaygockon oktaygockon
75 41%
Feb 17 coldesser
80 73%
Feb 14 gutterfly
68 15%
Feb 11 cemsancak cemsancak
95 97%
Feb 08 tom20 tom20
8 82%
Feb 08 Aizhas ()
60 16%
Feb 07 Theodore Ab
70 45%
Feb 02 t4lu t4lu
40 8%
Jan 31 salMovies
80 38%
Jan 28 jgreenwood jgreenwood
40 16%
Jan 26 larmor
62 40%
Great cinematography, but the story's a tad silly.
Jan 26 djross djross
20 2%
Shallow road movie with unconvincing characters, forced situations, contrived conflict, superficial (and exploitative) interest in history and fake (and exploitative) dramatic moments. Filming in black and white with heads framed at the bottom of the screen does not conceal these flaws, let alone compensate for them. And, while we're at it, don't end your desperate bid for artistic recognition by stealing Bach from Tarkovsky.
Jan 18 tai3tran
80 71%
Jan 16 username100
92 81%
Jan 15 ivanfreire
44 28%
Jan 15 kcknz kcknz
80 66%
Jan 14 shneebs
96 86%
Jan 14 cgdsn
92 78%
Jan 13 murats
66 35%
Jan 12 caffe
78 65%
Jan 11 thiskendell
40 67%
Jan 10 dinomut
89 48%
Jan 09 cengaveri
72 31%
Jan 05 Asabiyim_Ben Asabiyim Ben
90 65%
Jan 04 cascade cascade
83 84%
Jan 03 marcon65 marco_n65
81 85%
Jan 02 rafalko6
80 74%
Jan 02 eplpw
85 75%
Jan 01 jagdwire1
98 95%
Dec 31, 2017 Cigo Cigo
5 25%
Dec 28, 2017 tguarnaccia
90 76%
Dec 28, 2017 Ian Soz
85 33%
Dec 27, 2017 turhank
80 58%
Dec 22, 2017 careunicorn careunicorn
89 77%
Dec 21, 2017 filmdoc filmdoc
78 65%
Dec 20, 2017 ishekhter
99 96%
Dec 20, 2017 Systematicer
30 8%
Dec 19, 2017 bennick218
84 77%
Dec 18, 2017 ReCreation07 ReCreation07
89 66%
Dec 12, 2017 Koernia Koernia
70 66%
Dec 12, 2017 ironagepig ironagepig
99 93%
A quiet simple meditation on identity, especially Religious vs. Secular and Religious vs. Political. Regardless of what Pawlikowski personally believes he has successfully made one of the most wonderful depictions of faith and its role in identity formation and the repercussions of a completely secular world-view. The film's only shortcoming is its aspect ration which was at times distracting. But this is made up for by the film's overall style and quiet heart that beats under the surface.
Dec 10, 2017 CMWL
1 0%
Dec 06, 2017 pnk
70 17%
Nov 29, 2017 kidmaniac kidmaniac
76 68%
Nov 29, 2017 Cocoa
60 49%
Nov 28, 2017 bkam
80 71%
Nov 27, 2017 Bebop
8 72%
Nov 26, 2017 brkshn
80 74%
Nov 26, 2017 pvouvitu
92 91%
Nov 25, 2017 kjones77
80 70%
Nov 22, 2017 Tumerens Tumerens
92 82%
Nov 20, 2017 Muradhetf
95 75%
Nov 19, 2017 monoglot
80 84%
Nov 19, 2017 VitorHono
85 73%
Nov 19, 2017 Alsam
80 64%
Nov 18, 2017 emreyuksel emreyuksel
82 80%
Nov 16, 2017 wickermann
80 71%
Nov 06, 2017 udippuy
76 55%
Nov 06, 2017 Mpython Mpython
8 73%
Nov 03, 2017 sepid sepid
87 77%
Nov 01, 2017 mertbekt
70 32%
Oct 28, 2017 theWatcher
76 73%
Oct 28, 2017 CCTT
82 8%
Oct 27, 2017 kupfertj
78 68%
Oct 25, 2017 aalp aalp
7 71%
Oct 19, 2017 rakke
80 75%
Oct 17, 2017 Skg
30 43%
Oct 16, 2017 Liverpoole TarantinOle
78 72%
Oct 16, 2017 gonrodnu
60 40%
Oct 12, 2017 Jaifman Jaifman
56 15%
Oct 09, 2017 Farshad.sh.a
60 55%
Oct 05, 2017 himan1376
90 53%
Oct 01, 2017 sandrikoti
100 83%
Sep 27, 2017 mualde
85 59%
Sep 27, 2017 lezparanza
63 50%
Sep 26, 2017 Damirageir Damirageir
56 76%
Sep 24, 2017 natebarrios natebarrios
75 64%
Sep 24, 2017 Niyazi Niyazi
85 64%
Sep 23, 2017 chiefcuster chiefcuster
60 56%
Sep 17, 2017 PaulB1 PaulB1
81 58%
Sep 11, 2017 gregov_flick
56 68%
Sep 07, 2017 caprimode
90 84%
Sep 04, 2017 Born To Die
40 48%
Aug 29, 2017 pele
79 80%
Aug 29, 2017 tommy_leazaq
67 81%
Aug 20, 2017 Cerendes Cerendes
30 83%
Aug 19, 2017 Farsheed Farsheed
85 73%
Aug 18, 2017 EveAngel
70 58%
Aug 12, 2017 Herrguth Herrguth
77 87%
Aug 12, 2017 Kisbye
75 61%
Aug 12, 2017 ddarque
72 32%
Aug 08, 2017 Kyraen
78 70%
Aug 05, 2017 mesterlars mesterlars
80 47%
Aug 02, 2017 ganelon
80 48%
Jul 30, 2017 kandinya
60 39%
Jul 29, 2017 DarkCloud DarkCloud
90 83%
Singularly intense.
Jul 26, 2017 toytronicaz
70 49%
Jul 21, 2017 InnocentZ Innocent_Z
65 45%
Jul 18, 2017 dziabok dziabok
79 76%
Jul 17, 2017 EgOo EgOo
81 59%
Jul 16, 2017 gonuldurmaz gonuldurmaz
90 83%
Jul 16, 2017 zahrast
82 50%
Jul 15, 2017 kenny_knp
70 53%
Jul 10, 2017 didaahe didaahe
98 98%
Jul 08, 2017 tinatinas tinatinas
70 45%
Jul 08, 2017 bdurmaz bdurmaz
79 79%
Jul 07, 2017 naghashbashi naghashbashi
70 39%
Jul 05, 2017 FreddieQuell FreddieQuell
49 33%
Jul 04, 2017 Sabila Sabila
80 70%
Jul 03, 2017 addeh addeh
93 97%
Jun 25, 2017 vernonsong vernonsong
80 51%
Jun 24, 2017 AHP
90 93%
Jun 22, 2017 Visocchi
80 24%
Jun 22, 2017 insider4
84 55%
Jun 21, 2017 RYM_byrates RYM-byrates
69 75%
Jun 19, 2017 YMSFake
80 85%
Jun 17, 2017 Arlowe Arlowe_
68 59%
Jun 14, 2017 oguzaksu
90 83%
Jun 13, 2017 parichehr
75 32%
Jun 07, 2017 sagikk
90 94%
Jun 03, 2017 sperkins55
90 32%
Jun 01, 2017 PsyDystopia
55 28%
May 30, 2017 aymansousa aymansousa
60 52%
May 29, 2017 jamiro
90 56%
May 27, 2017 bleaker
85 66%
May 24, 2017 Phil_Clowns Phil Clowns
55 11%
May 15, 2017 DrWade42
90 92%
May 13, 2017 HKi HKi
73 65%
May 12, 2017 HillJackBob
40 8%
May 10, 2017 albajos
50 40%
May 04, 2017 oskarhu oskarhu
78 61%
Ida is beautifully shot and the actors play their roles well. Never got exciting for me, as most scenes were quite boring despite the film's poetic nature being handled with style for the most part.
May 01, 2017 osmanliemre Hamido
78 82%
Apr 25, 2017 2017kah
80 49%
Apr 20, 2017 kendell kendell
88 73%
Apr 12, 2017 Hamid2net Hamid2net
80 35%
Apr 10, 2017 Philosofem
81 82%
Apr 09, 2017 parasol94 parasol94
75 65%
Apr 09, 2017 PSCriticker
75 2%
Apr 09, 2017 ICMforum
80 23%
Apr 07, 2017 cayh
90 89%
Apr 04, 2017 luc luc
60 29%
Apr 02, 2017 vahidtamimi
84 81%
Mar 29, 2017 birdhunter
75 26%
Mar 27, 2017 lancaster lancaster
91 88%
Mar 25, 2017 agzel agzel
90 82%
Mar 24, 2017 amirtocha amirtocha
75 65%
Mar 23, 2017 NoSex NoSex
80 71%
Mar 18, 2017 loosecanons loosecanons
9 78%
Mar 16, 2017 habeck
52 3%
Mar 15, 2017 holsgr holsgr
7 75%
Mar 09, 2017 mamalizoli mamali_zoli
100 99%
Mar 09, 2017 WillyV
81 90%
Mar 08, 2017 mkrusell
83 90%
Mar 07, 2017 pja
65 60%
Feb 26, 2017 sweetpeas
67 37%
Feb 26, 2017 dr_Robert
5 94%
Bitvis väl långsam, men bitvis är filmen också väldigt stark. Vackert foto, ful och skitig polsk landsbygd med mörka hemligheter. Manuskriptet lyckas på nåt märkligt men övertygande sätt gifta ihop tre genrer: roadmovien, övergången från flicka till kvinna och the holocaust. "Ida" är inte bara oerhört vacker, huvudrollsinnehavarens rolltolkning imponerar.
Feb 25, 2017 lineuphere lineuphere
83 75%
Feb 25, 2017 mCihhh mCihhh
80 81%
Feb 24, 2017 Panunzio
74 58%
Feb 23, 2017 branledore
78 51%
Feb 21, 2017 kode
91 94%
Feb 19, 2017 mew
50 18%
Feb 16, 2017 ube ube
7 54%
Feb 13, 2017 orcunselvi orcunselvi
64 59%
Feb 12, 2017 feranmeraler feranmeraler
83 75%
Feb 12, 2017 Yiannos Yiannos
73 71%
(Rewatched 16/11/17): Comparisons to Dreyer and Bergman are inevitable but create unrealistic expectations. It is undeniably well crafted, thoughtful and perhaps even brave in how it addresses Poland's dark past, but it is a tad contrived and eager to please fans of this particular style of minimalist cinema. Much care has evidently gone into its compositions which capture movements on the frame's periphery, and Trzebuchowska makes a strong impression as Ida.
Feb 09, 2017 Dijkschneier
60 7%
Feb 09, 2017 serinkuytu serinkuytu
90 86%
Feb 08, 2017 devinallen devin_allen
90 59%
Feb 07, 2017 bhalac bhalac
80 70%
Feb 07, 2017 ManyPany ManyPany
73 83%
Feb 06, 2017 ns_ian
80 69%
Feb 06, 2017 topitop
88 98%
Feb 05, 2017 kubrickvari kubrickvari
40 10%
Feb 03, 2017 guigux
53 10%
Feb 02, 2017 howler19 howler19
34 25%
Jan 31, 2017 Unununium
80 93%
Jan 29, 2017 NevinLiu
78 63%
Jan 26, 2017 bitterbill bitterbill
40 28%
Jan 24, 2017 nifwl
9 59%
Jan 23, 2017 megasorde
75 67%
Jan 22, 2017 Glebaster
68 69%
Jan 17, 2017 gorkemoge gorkemoge
75 80%
Jan 14, 2017 mjbreuer
76 67%
Jan 13, 2017 smellyjoe
85 70%
Jan 10, 2017 Chr_Bach Chr. Bach
70 56%
Jan 09, 2017 fre
70 63%
Jan 01, 2017 Aqy_
8 67%
Dec 30, 2016 cranky cranky
66 51%
Dec 27, 2016 joachimt joachimt
90 96%
Dec 24, 2016 Stanley Stanley
72 38%
Dec 23, 2016 fakefeudal fakefeudal
90 82%
Dec 23, 2016 robochaa
90 91%
Dec 20, 2016 anaskvit anaskvit
80 63%
Dec 20, 2016 bidola
83 75%
Dec 20, 2016 fakoushhh
80 71%
Dec 19, 2016 soleo
82 87%
Dec 19, 2016 explorer95
6 47%
Displaying 1 to 250 of 1060 total rankings: Prev | Next
Average Percentile 59.36% from 1060 Rankings rss