McCabe & Mrs. Miller (1971)

Probable Score

Not Enough Info

Your Score

(0 - 100)

Set in winter in the Old West. Charismatic but dumb John McCabe arrives in a young Pacific Northwest town to set up a whorehouse/tavern (imdb)

More Film Information and Actions

Genres: Drama, Western

AKA: McCabe and Mrs. Miller

Country: USA

Directed By: Robert Altman

Written By: Robert Altman, Edmund Naughton, Brian McKay

Starring: Julie Christie, Warren Beatty, William Devane, Shelley Duvall, Michael Murphy, Rene Auberjonois, John Schuck, Corey Fischer, Keith Carradine, Bert Remsen, Hugh Millais, Antony Holland

RatingsRatings

FindFind

CollectionsCollections

StatsStats

Loading Products from Ebay

Loading...
loading

McCabe & Mrs. Miller belongs to 76 collections

1. 1001 Movies You Must See Before You Die (public: moderated by kozan26 - 191 stars)

2. Criterion Collection (public: moderated by caffe - 136 stars)

3. Roger Ebert: Great Movies (public: moderated by PeaceAnarchy - 71 stars)

4. boobs (public: moderated by Pickpocket - 43 stars)

5. They Shoot Pictures 1,000 Greatest Films (2008 revision) (public: moderated by Scottathon - 37 stars)

6. Jonathan Rosenbaum's Top 1000 Movies (public: moderated by PeaceAnarchy - 34 stars)

7. They Shoot Pictures 1,000 Greatest Films (2010 revision) (public: moderated by MMAlpha - 32 stars)

8. Martin Scorsese's Film School: The 85 Films You Need to See to Know Anything About Film (public - 29 stars)

9. New York Times' The Best 1,000 Movies Ever Made (public: moderated by theficionado - 27 stars)

10. They Shoot Pictures 1,000 Greatest Films (2014 revision) (public: moderated by Jehan - 27 stars)

11. The Guardian's 1000 films to see before you die (public: moderated by PeaceAnarchy - 24 stars)

12. They Shoot Pictures 1,000 Greatest Films (2012 revision) (public: moderated by PeaceAnarchy - 24 stars)

13. National Film Registry (public: moderated by PeaceAnarchy - 22 stars)

14. List: Empire's five star movies (public: moderated by KasperL - 17 stars)

15. Academy Award - Oscar - ALL Best Picture, Directing, Acting & Screenplay Nominees (public - 17 stars)

16. They Shoot Pictures 1,000 Greatest Films (2013 revision) (public: moderated by rant1229 - 16 stars)

17. They Shoot Pictures' Recommended Viewing (public: moderated by Cinephile - 15 stars)

18. The Story of Film: An Odyssey (public: moderated by rant1229 - 15 stars)

19. They Shoot Pictures 1,000 Greatest Films (2011 revision) (public: moderated by PeaceAnarchy - 14 stars)

20. They Shoot Pictures 1,000 Greatest Films (2017 revision) (public: moderated by dookobore - 13 stars)

21. Slant Magazine's 100 Essential Films (public: moderated by nexus - 12 stars)

22. Films available in HD (public: moderated by kubricksucks - 12 stars)

23. New Hollywood (public: moderated by saudade - 12 stars)

24. Best of criticker: Drama (public: moderated by avgcrtckr - 12 stars)

25. Great color cinematography (public: moderated by Alex Watkins - 11 stars)

26. films101.com's 5 star films (public: moderated by ppinocchio - 11 stars)

27. Best film of top directors (public: moderated by avgcrtckr - 11 stars)

28. Based On A Book (public: moderated by Spunkie - 10 stars)

29. Sight and Sound 2002 (public: moderated by PeaceAnarchy - 9 stars)

30. Prostitution (public: moderated by Moribunny - 6 stars)

31. David Thomson's 1000 Films (public: moderated by MMAlpha - 6 stars)

32. Criticker top 250 (public: moderated by avgcrtckr - 6 stars)

33. Based On Novel (public: moderated by tathiel - 5 stars)

34. Jonathan Rosenbaum's Alternative Top 100 (public: moderated by dookobore - 5 stars)

35. They Shoot Pictures 1,000 Greatest Films (2007 revision) (public: moderated by Scottathon - 4 stars)

36. AFI - 10 Top 10 Western (public: moderated by CCLZA - 3 stars)

37. Anamorphic Cinematography (public: moderated by Bojangles - 3 stars)

38. Best of criticker: Western (public: moderated by avgcrtckr - 3 stars)

39. Films Photographed by Vilmos Zsigmond (public: moderated by dookobore - 2 stars)

40. Female Bath Scene (public - 1 star)

41. List: Empire's masterpiece picks (public: moderated by KasperL - 1 star)

42. Sound Design (public: moderated by paulofilmo - 1 star)

43. BBC 100 Greatest American Films (public: moderated by jeff_v - 1 star)

44. Average Percentile >70 (public: moderated by peyrin - 1 star)

45. Roger Ebert's Top 10 Films of 1971 (public)

46. Westerns set in Washington (public: moderated by Moribunny)

47. Derek Malcolm's Century of Films (public: moderated by MMAlpha)

48. AFI - 10 Top 10 (All) (public: moderated by Phantom Nook)

49. Empire's 500 Greatest Movies Of All Time (private: Ross - 32 stars)

50. Cinema Discusso: Movies You Should See (private - 31 stars)

51. Cinema Discusso Yearly Consensus (2008) (private: PeaceAnarchy - 10 stars)

52. The Village Voice: 150 Groundbreaking Films (private: kevinjoseph - 6 stars)

53. Djross best Westerns (private: djross - 4 stars)

54. Coheed's Films I Need To See Or Try To Track Down (private: Coheed - 3 stars)

55. Djross movies that transcend their genre (private: djross - 2 stars)

56. edkrak films to see (private: edkrak - 2 stars)

57. Djross Western of the decade (private: djross - 2 stars)

58. Djross great movies (private: djross - 2 stars)

59. Films listed as Harmony Korine's favorites. (private: karamazov. - 2 stars)

60. KAH's movies of the year.. (private: KAH - 1 star)

61. Djross English-language feature of the year (private: djross - 1 star)

62. Favorites of Each Year (private: Actionberg)

63. PSI being off (private: JooJoo)

64. recommended by welshy and rainman (private: kubricksucks)

65. Djross 1971 top ten (private: djross)

66. 1971: Year in Review (private: polanski28)

67. Favorites: Highly recommended (private: KasperL)

68. Filmspotting Ratings Project: Week 5 (private: PeaceAnarchy)

69. Cinetheque (private: sdenka)

70. luke9's Top 101 Favorite Movies (private)

71. DVR (private: svenerik)

72. Jodie's Feature Film of the Year (private: jgreenwood)

73. KENDELL'S MASSIVE LIST (private: kendell)

74. Tom's Movies (private: tomwalsh)

75. to-do (private: chxflx)

76. Mr. Hallenbeck's Blu-Ray Wishlist (private: MrHallenbeck)

Browse the full list of collections

Show:

All Ratings | With Reviews

Order by:

TCI | Percentile | Date Rated | # Stars (Reviews)

Date	User	Rating
Jan 15	Ceekay19	65 _51%
John McCabe: "If a frog had wings, he wouldn't bump his ass so much, follow me?"
Jan 11	P u l p	83 _88%
It is you my love, you who are the stranger.
Jan 10	Teerak	70 _55%
Jan 06	katsuben	5 _85%
Jan 06	gossamer2019	77 _80%
Jan 04	ElsaH	89 _82%
Jan 04	Kabbjeh	90 _96%
Jan 04	sadbear	84 _82%
Jan 01	FraGil	80 _83%
Dec 26, 2018	Dingleberry	100 _86%
Dec 24, 2018	knives	60 _8%
Dec 19, 2018	B7Chrome	99 _83%
Dec 14, 2018	M_A	78 _74%
Nov 20, 2018	vitruvian	85 _57%
Nov 17, 2018	Dom92	100 _94%
Nov 12, 2018	Pugs4Less	96 _91%
Nov 11, 2018	kappeuter	80 _%
Nov 09, 2018	sufjan	70 _%
Nov 04, 2018	ifbrown11	96 _99%
Oct 25, 2018	eespo93	95 _97%
Oct 23, 2018	AntoniusBlok	81 _40%
Oct 19, 2018	Shitbanger	99 _89%
Oct 19, 2018	HarrisonOh	70 _22%
Oct 09, 2018	brickwall	85 _86%
You can tell at a glance how important McCabe & Mrs. Miller was to film history.
Oct 07, 2018	skydog	85 _75%
Oct 03, 2018	bmmello	84 _78%
Oct 01, 2018	Hyperion+	62 _89%
Sep 21, 2018	donmateo	55 _45%
Sep 20, 2018	ShaunLewis54	86 _76%
Sep 12, 2018	Candiru	90 _95%
Sep 11, 2018	zelda	91 _69%
Sep 09, 2018	Zepheus	70 _%
Aug 15, 2018	drdutw	94 _98%
Aug 10, 2018	kritikos	7 _39%
Aug 10, 2018	capodelnulla	90 _94%
ne kadar doğaçlama dahil olursa olsun, altman'ın hiçbir koreografi yokmuş izlenimi veren çekimleri, kalabalık sahneleri yansıtışı, kasabayı görüşü şaşırtıcı biçimde "gerçeğe" yakınsatıyor hikayeyi. özellikle karakterler üzerinden gelen janr oynamaları bu sayede çok daha çekici oluyor. hikaye boyu takip eden hüzünlü mü sadece gündelik mi belli olmayan his finalde son vuruşunu yapıyor.
Aug 07, 2018	filmbantha	60 _31%
Aug 06, 2018	Diggler	65 _36%
Jul 28, 2018	shanebarlow3	87 _88%
Jul 27, 2018	cascade	73 _59%
Jul 26, 2018	CMQuinn	30 _5%
Jul 22, 2018	kennkoon	85 _93%
Jul 20, 2018	Tavarish	95 _93%
Jul 14, 2018	Nathers7	3 _43%
Jul 14, 2018	2PCwV0	80 _%
Jul 13, 2018	Anomaly1	80 _73%
Works better as a mood piece than as a character piece, especially since it's a bit lopsided in that regard. But the characters are still great, and the realistic depiction of the time period is particularly compelling.
Jul 12, 2018	ehk2	62 _79%
I couldn't get it. If this is an adaptation from a novel, we should have got more depth about individuals, their background, motivations, etc. The movie on the other hand, much spends its time on broader social dynamics. But for me, for all its shallowness, it admittedly has a certain 'mood' -especially thanks to the songs, colour palette and melancholic stares of the two leading actors... [perhaps they're running away from their past and being dragged from place to place, I don't know - possibl
Jul 09, 2018	ethsings72	95 _91%
Jul 08, 2018	oguzkayir	6 _48%
Jul 03, 2018	oben	86 _88%
Jun 29, 2018	dracular	80 _70%
Jun 20, 2018	FreddieQuell	95 _96%
May 31, 2018	HogluHulu	23 _22%
May 28, 2018	Amir abbas	79 _90%
May 22, 2018	ForrestQ	78 _64%
May 22, 2018	pyrosexual	78 _51%
Really picks up at the end
May 20, 2018	rospo	64 _52%
May 19, 2018	Reusdrigo	80 _65%
May 16, 2018	drnkurmlkshk	70 _65%
May 15, 2018	Hadzibegovic	81 _80%
May 10, 2018	normatic	90 _96%
May 09, 2018	Grandaddy	80 _88%
May 08, 2018	brennanc	87 _78%
May 07, 2018	Siegel Hans	80 _82%
May 04, 2018	Sejanus	100 _80%
May 01, 2018	John Milton	80 _87%
Apr 29, 2018	allneonslike	83 _92%
Apr 28, 2018	MrBadSmile	85 _56%
Apr 19, 2018	fictionfitz	97 _99%
Apr 15, 2018	AchwellFoley	80 _89%
Apr 14, 2018	myriadVoles	100 _89%
Apr 13, 2018	benrad	60 _27%
Apr 13, 2018	dourface	70 _67%
Apr 10, 2018	Muk	100 _95%
Apr 10, 2018	mate_cosido	45 _15%
Apr 03, 2018	kafka1325	50 _31%
Mar 19, 2018	apsays	87 _92%
Mar 09, 2018	skap	90 _73%
As could be expected from Altman, it's perfectly deprived of the usual cinematic ostentation and explicitness and yet very cinematic, in its own way. Just like in real life, one never really penetrates beyond the physical shells of the characters, which makes the love story subtle to non-existent. Rather demanding like a good book, but when you get to the end of it, you feel rewarded, and start making plans of rereading it.
Mar 04, 2018	adamj1982	78 _74%
Feb 27, 2018	JaycetJayce	60 _25%
Feb 26, 2018	darkbloom	100 _97%
Feb 25, 2018	LouisMazzini	89 _98%
Feb 17, 2018	coldesser	80 _73%
Feb 08, 2018	unaga	85 _63%
Feb 02, 2018	JurijFedorov	70 _66%
Jan 30, 2018	Obdurate	80 _64%
I had a bit of a time getting invested but this is a beautifully shot anti-Western where great performances by both Christie and Beatty. Although the Cohen score is wonderful, occasionally it would get used in a silly way; felt some of the placing was odd. Not a lot happens but even today it is nice to see such a low-key premise explored.
Jan 29, 2018	gackt	70 _58%
Jan 23, 2018	maxmode	50 _23%
Jan 15, 2018	ZONE	100 _91%
Jan 09, 2018	cengaveri	75 _61%
Jan 02, 2018	rafalko6	60 _30%
Jan 01, 2018	KubrickCube	80 _70%
Dec 26, 2017	Xzlu	6 _51%
Dec 24, 2017	Old_Spriggan	75 _58%
Dec 24, 2017	greekgrits	91 _91%
Dec 20, 2017	bennick218	85 _78%
Dec 20, 2017	Systematicer	70 _69%
Dec 09, 2017	CMWL	1 _0%
Dec 08, 2017	benotoole	88 _83%
Nov 29, 2017	Cocoa	30 _3%
Nov 29, 2017	quotidian	7 _38%
Nov 25, 2017	kjones77	90 _93%
Nov 18, 2017	Fumbles	84 _60%
Nov 17, 2017	teaty666	70 _88%
Nov 15, 2017	jpn	3 _35%
Nov 15, 2017	rosenritter	7 _72%
Is it just me or does Julie Christie look a bit like Klaus Kinski? // What the hell, that lanky kid was Keith Carradine? // Video game idea #138: A tranquil, Harvest Moon-esque simulation game in which you play as the proprietor of a whorehouse in a snowy frontier town.
Oct 29, 2017	crazythinker	1 _0%
Oct 28, 2017	volken	75 _37%
Oct 24, 2017	danozu	80 _81%
Oct 21, 2017	inverness	90 _67%
Oct 14, 2017	fernsebner	80 _58%
Oct 13, 2017	Kobaruon	40 _17%
Oct 10, 2017	mike365365	83 _95%
Oct 01, 2017	sandrikoti	90 _56%
Sep 29, 2017	CinemaLover7	85 _56%
Sep 18, 2017	kode	89 _88%
Sep 16, 2017	Asm Nabil	75 _59%
Sep 10, 2017	spacemanmoth	10 _94%
Sep 07, 2017	turand	84 _55%
Sep 04, 2017	fabiovisnadi	92 _85%
Aug 13, 2017	Walterpoa	73 _62%
Aug 12, 2017	NhanLa	73 _65%
Aug 11, 2017	DrWade42	92 _95%
Aug 02, 2017	whataboutit	90 _74%
Jul 23, 2017	tomatwork	30 _29%
Jul 22, 2017	izefferino13	82 _30%
Jul 21, 2017	Toke Za	90 _94%
Jul 14, 2017	haljordan2	1 _%
Jul 12, 2017	TraverseTown	60 _47%
Jul 11, 2017	Philosofem	80 _77%
Jul 09, 2017	NathanBates	60 _35%
Jun 24, 2017	NBD Rab	85 _80%
Jun 18, 2017	guvolefou	80 _75%
Jun 18, 2017	jagarnyfiken	85 _91%
Jun 17, 2017	Arlowe_	85 _91%
Jun 12, 2017	xmoffx	4 _67%
Jun 05, 2017	kharms	50 _28%
May 29, 2017	frbrown	65 _19%
May 27, 2017	SirStuckey	80 _78%
I'm not the biggest Altman fan but I really enjoyed this one. Beatty and Christie were perfect as entrepreneurs (for lack of a better word) in a new town and the town itself had a wonderful life to it. It's kind of a tough watch at the beginning but as the movie goes on it becomes quite easy to warm up to.
May 20, 2017	barryegan	80 _48%
May 10, 2017	albajos	50 _40%
May 09, 2017	Jo Alves	90 _80%
May 06, 2017	42ffKANEddd	5 _90%
Apr 16, 2017	Batty	75 _61%
Apr 09, 2017	LuxNatalis	75 _83%
Apr 09, 2017	ICMforum	90 _62%
Apr 05, 2017	92filmgeek	54 _26%
Mar 29, 2017	j_montanaro	90 _60%
Mar 26, 2017	bybrt	70 _65%
Mar 25, 2017	mvsilva	89 _89%
Mar 23, 2017	tneeld	100 _98%
Mar 20, 2017	thrillington	60 _9%
Mar 14, 2017	lineuphere	90 _91%
Mar 10, 2017	RYM-byrates	78 _97%
Mar 05, 2017	smellyjoe	100 _95%
Feb 26, 2017	dr_Robert	4 _73%
Feb 25, 2017	lisko	80 _78%
Feb 25, 2017	mCihhh	70 _60%
Feb 23, 2017	chineyman	90 _97%
Feb 21, 2017	JohnT	100 _93%
Feb 17, 2017	Averman004	90 _93%
Feb 14, 2017	Buff	45 _63%
Feb 14, 2017	Gnalkthere	90 _87%
The lost feminist masterpiece of our time.
Feb 13, 2017	Jimmy Suede	20 _7%
If you don't like traditional westerns, adventure, beautiful scenery or characters with anything noble about them, this revisionist western might be for you. If you do like stories with more "realism", indecent people you don't really care about, miserable conditions, dark lighting and lots of whores, this might be your kind of movie. Alas, it isn't mine. Also, Cohen's score makes you feel like this is a poetic tragedy about an everyman you can relate to, belied by the movie itself.
Feb 12, 2017	SeanBerndorff	75 _64%
Feb 10, 2017	jsa86_86	60 _24%
Feb 03, 2017	jerfairall	90 _94%
Jan 19, 2017	Ringshifter	92 _94%
Jan 19, 2017	Robert Frost	86 _56%
Jan 17, 2017	Reavic	70 _82%
Jan 16, 2017	drstrangeluv	100 _99%
Jan 14, 2017	Randomperson	89 _63%
Jan 12, 2017	mjbreuer	74 _59%
Jan 12, 2017	joewkeh	90 _98%
Jan 11, 2017	castanpod	80 _79%
Jan 09, 2017	leemarvins	87 _93%
Jan 02, 2017	Tarris1	73 _24%
Jan 02, 2017	???	73 _67%
Jan 02, 2017	felsonprison	94 _59%
Jan 02, 2017	imdbtv	76 _74%
Dec 27, 2016	Rebert	8 _87%
Dec 22, 2016	00noone	95 _87%
Dec 21, 2016	bidola	83 _73%
Dec 09, 2016	goatsupply	90 _84%
Dec 07, 2016	Triptolemos	70 _74%
Dec 03, 2016	maxcoombes	90 _95%
Dec 01, 2016	nunobar	80 _69%
Nov 28, 2016	chester9876	75 _67%
Nov 25, 2016	CesarCastag (CinePlayers.com)	90 _84%
Nov 22, 2016	meliorism	75 _65%
Nov 21, 2016	matty5190	89 _87%
Nov 21, 2016	catso	80 _73%
Nov 18, 2016	marco_n65	77 _56%
Nov 14, 2016	Boonmee	75 _56%
Nov 14, 2016	cinegeek.de	90 _79%
(...)Überhaupt; man beachte den Titel: McCabe & Mrs. Miller. Das verheisst keinerlei persönliche Beziehung, klingt wie ein Firmenname. Ein geschäftliches Arrangement. Alles, was Mrs. Miller tut, ist geschäftlich. Was mag sie hinter sich haben? Sicher nur; sie liess alles zurück. Der arme McCabe. Er mag ein Poet sein, doch das ist einerlei in Presbyterian Church. Mrs. Miller wird wohl die Einzige in der Stadt sein, die überhaupt weiss, was Poesie bedeutet. Doch sie liess auch das zurück; b
Nov 12, 2016	Gossamer	2 _61%
Nov 10, 2016	Ronin22	79 _97%
Nov 06, 2016	jgreenwood	85 _88%
Nov 05, 2016	svenerik	78 _50%
Nov 02, 2016	jerrywarton	81 _93%
Oct 31, 2016	zkas1225	69 _48%
Oct 30, 2016	hyrras	80 _73%
Oct 28, 2016	dequinix	60 _46%
Oct 28, 2016	teckgecko	80 _85%
Oct 28, 2016	Tester	81 _84%
Oct 22, 2016	Yiannos	85 _96%
Rightly praised for its murky visuals, innovative sound design and its trenchant critique of contemporary capitalism, McCabe & Mrs Miller remains one of the greatest and most original achievements of New Hollywood. Beatty excels as the bumbling McCabe, a would be entrepreneur who lacks the brains and know-how to succeed in an increasingly cut throat world. But it's Zsigmond's haunting, moody and sensual photography that stuns and leaves the deepest imprint, creating a truly singular experience.
Oct 18, 2016	TheMarkle	90 _96%
Oct 17, 2016	Barbudo	80 _38%
Oct 15, 2016	blanketstate	9 _82%
Oct 15, 2016	herpico	9 _9%
Sep 30, 2016	BreesKnees	85 _34%
Sep 29, 2016	kupfertj	89 _94%
Sep 28, 2016	Metropolitan	85 _85%
Sep 19, 2016	scarletspeed	67 _73%
Sep 19, 2016	mixjuice	87 _89%
Sep 18, 2016	cankutozturk	78 _81%
Aug 27, 2016	NickP	90 _96%
Aug 14, 2016	Mpython	7 _57%
Aug 13, 2016	EastonD	93 _91%
Jul 31, 2016	Evan D	20 _3%
Jul 25, 2016	matthewmj336	93 _86%
Jul 24, 2016	Mubear	89 _95%
Jul 20, 2016	Archeologian	75 _75%
Excellent performances all round, gorgeously shot, and the Leonard Cohen soundtrack adds a peculiar but fascinating tonality. I was specifically interested in the stabbing scene, which is also masterfully orchestrated.
Jul 13, 2016	eddiewinslow	80 _57%
Jul 12, 2016	ryanb	66 _43%
Jul 04, 2016	Col_Needham	80 _78%
Jul 04, 2016	MrWhiplash	90 _69%
Jun 30, 2016	bal3x	70 _69%
Jun 23, 2016	Bown	89 _89%
Jun 21, 2016	Squin	85 _72%
Jun 08, 2016	E.C.R.	78 _92%
Jun 04, 2016	letterboxdvo	41 _95%
Jun 03, 2016	trippingly	90 _75%
May 17, 2016	thirdeye42	78 _80%
May 06, 2016	SirTeaBag	9 _91%
Apr 24, 2016	mdhillyer	95 _63%
Apr 15, 2016	fannyoch	100 _92%
Apr 13, 2016	Hipsteresque	94 _92%
Apr 13, 2016	Skerringer	86 _94%
Apr 08, 2016	Mencius	80 _62%
Apr 08, 2016	Usonian	93 _85%
Apr 07, 2016	kingofsuede	100 _94%
Apr 02, 2016	mimecry	85 _39%
Mar 28, 2016	darius	97 _76%
Mar 24, 2016	eassin	73 _83%
Mar 22, 2016	Chrysophylax	80 _74%
Mar 21, 2016	tommy_leazaq	57 _54%
Mar 16, 2016	drpretenamen	95 _91%
Mar 11, 2016	M-B-M	8 _95%
Mar 07, 2016	atimetolive	5 _82%
Mar 06, 2016	FrancoZero	17 _90%

Displaying 1 to 250 of 1108 total ratings: Prev | Next

Average Percentile 71.93% from 1108 Ratings