Sin City: A Dame to Kill For

I like the visual style and the atmosphere. The story with Eva Green is not bad, but the other 2 (or 1.5) feels a bit tacked on, or at least their wrap-up feels like part of an overlong ending rather than being an independent entity.

Just doesn't live up to it's predecessor

Somehow not as punchy as the first one, in spite of a solid cast. It's hard to explain how but I don't think I can blame it all on losing its novelty. Johnny's story feels a bit useless no matter what he says, because of the last chapter.

Although this film was nearly a decade in the making I felt it was as fun and visually great to watch as the first in the series. Some of the main characters return and its as if they have never been away. The script ties up some of the loose ends and also does a decent job of introducing a new audience to Sin City. I don't think the stories are as good as the previous film but I was captivated throughout and left me craving for more. Hopefully it wont be another 10 year wait for another sequel.

The movie looks ugly, the movie is acted ugly and the film treats its viewer with absolutely no respect. What a disappointment. Don't watch this one.

not good

A cheap, unoriginal "sequel" to one of the most stylistically accomplished neo noirs of all time. Not even Eva Green's breathtaking allure can rescue this film from being a boring, meandering maze.