Criticker.com - Film & TV Recommendations and Community
profile
login | register
0 rankings

Song of the South ()

Probable Score
Not Enough Info
Your Rating

Summary: Uncle Remus draws upon his tales of Brer Rabbit to help little Johnny deal his confusion over his parents'... (imdb)

Genres: Family/Kids, Adventure, Animation, Music

Country: USA

Directed By: Wilfred Jackson, Harve Foster

Written By: Joel Chandler Harris, Dalton S. Reymond

Starring: Ruth Warrick, Lucile Watson, Bobby Driscoll, James Baskett, Luana Patten, Hattie McDaniel

Additional Information & Actions

More information at IMDb

StatsStats
CollectionsCollections
FindFind
RatingsRatings
loading Loading Products from Ebay
Loading...
loading
Song of the South belongs to 23 collections
1. Disney's Theatrical Live-Action (public: moderated by Vesey - 2 stars)
2. Oscar: Best Original Song (public: moderated by monclivie - 1 star)
3. Highest grossing film of the year (public: moderated by djross - 1 star)
4. 3-strip Technicolor films (your public collection - 1 star) | remove from collection
5. Musicals (public: moderated by BeeDub - 1 star)
6. Highest Grossing Films by Year (public: moderated by whatismyname)
7. Gregg Toland (public: moderated by jodamico)
8. Nostalgia Critic - Disneycember (public: moderated by Phantom Nook)
9. rjonkdkfehv (your private collection - 8 stars) | remove from collection
10. Coheed's Celluloid Pit (private: Coheed)
11. Ignored Films (your private collection) | remove from collection
12. Filmspotting Ratings Project: Week 15 (private: PeaceAnarchy)
13. Welcome to the Basement (private: donkeyjelly)
14. Carolina Theater Retro Films (private: djcrawfo)
15. Rated (private: giska)


Browse the full list of collections
Show:
All Rankings | With Reviews
Order by:
TCI User Score
Dunstan_xxx Dunstan-xxx
71T8
maddog maddog
83T8
jarvlia
20T2
Gordon_Cole Gordon Cole
78T7
Scarface Scarface
74T7
Shadrik Shadrik
20T1
Warren Warren
55T1
This is a film with a real troubled legacy, but the end result for me is more of a bored shrug than moral outrage or scandal. It's not overly racist, I don't think (its heart is in the right place), but it's just so full of quaint, old-timey southern cliches that it's kind of a boring experience. The animated scenes don't even offer much in terms of inventiveness or humour. James Baskett's performance is steeped in cliche but he's an appropriately pleasant and genial presence for a kids' film.
mlpgaffney mlpgaffney
67T3
manwich
90T9
margot margot
1T1
ForrestQ ForrestQ
65T3
jwmartin
90T8
nymsa
90T10
boothmillard
50T3
youtellme93
5T1
Racism aside, this isn't amusing or entertaining in the slightest. Thumbs down.
JaJunk
91T10
imdb imdb
74T9
moodeuce
70T6
monoglot
60T5
Mulholland Mulholland
40T2
rottentomat rottentomat
40T3
aethling
60T4
loucypher loucypher
65T4
DougReese DougReese
65T7
Adobe Slats
97T10
Elfflame Elfflame
72T3
winds winds
6T8
rant1229 rant1229
2T3
mlingkh
78T7
abricru abricru
80T9
elcalculator
63T6
mitchelly mitchelly
80T4
sceptre_777
60T5
RedFalcon Red_Falcon_
72T6
The song Zip-a-Doo-Dah and James Basket's performance as Uncle Remus are the highlights of this lower tier film from Disney's Golden Age.
OnTarget On_Target
50T3
PeaceAnarchy PeaceAnarchy
53T1
Hey, it's offensive and incredibly boring, what a winning combination. I think the animated parts may have been decent, but I've tried to block as much of this film as possible from my memory.
PrinceKaro PrinceKaro
50T4
kangadoodoo kangadoodoo
50T4
b0ger
60T5
TartanLlama
60T4
zachheltzel zachheltzel
50T4
Not_Yuman Not Yuman
20T2
Caracortada
70T9
Mentaculus Mentaculus
80T8
The live-action/animation combo scenes are unbelievable, with Baskett's phenomenal acting carrys the film's suspension of disbelief. While I do admit the Tar-Baby scene is racist, I don't think the rest of it is. Remus becomes a father figure to the young boy, and so is treated positively (to be honest, it's the same basic plot structure as Mary Poppins). My personal caveat: if Gone With the Wind can be loved and appreciated and sold in the US, this should be too. It's probably even less racist.
CinemaVerite
82T9
DaeSanye DaeSanye
5T4
BartonFink
6T6
Exsilium
75T10
hotsake hotsake
59T4
laughy
90T10
ThePunisher ThePunisher
72T8
DalenQuaice Dalen_Quaice
40T4
flyingwhales
85T8
Zaltys Zaltys
32T3
Chibichi
89T8
Ralph Hall
100T8
preppy-3
80T8
scarletspeed scarletspeed
46T5
LetsGoEatHuh LetsGoEatHuh
55T6
rTrueFilm r/TrueFilm
40T1
beckers1021 beckers1021
45T7
BillyShears BillyShears
70T6
Riverbelle Riverbelle
100T10
jksterup jksterup
80T4
MrHedgepig MrHedgepig
85T4
goldbluming Goldbluming
34T1
How can something be so boring and offensive at the same time?
waitsup waitsup
70T8
kylie kylie
56T6
penguin
75T8
cdalepirate
40T3
Stim immolations
30T4
mikerog12
70T5
baconadidas bacon&adidas
50T1
LazarBloom
50T1
zetes
90T9
redpatriot redpatriot
72T7
RavynLoony
51T5
mynameisdoug mynameisdoug
100T10
DrewTheDude DrewTheDude
65T7
Jyan
77T5
FreddieQuell FreddieQuell
77T7
mallamp
70T6
naviniea naviniea
50T4
unohav1 unohav_1
80T5
Esmerodo Esmerodo
60T3
jeffayle
60T2
filmaffinity filmaffinity
63T6
OldAle1
80T6
Dicke_Taube
70T6
LooseEnd LooseEnd
50T6
sheesh
84T5
herge
60T6
tmaustin89
93T10
kingofjew kingofjew
74T6
jeffv jeff_v
64T4
rb42083
80T6
CloseFriend CloseFriend
49T3
Fetsch
69T5
cayh
60T3
remusclaw
75T4
Cronos
60T6
IsaacFord IsaacFord
70T2
haljordan2 haljordan2
46T5
Antares Antares
72T7
Rocketo Rocketo
80T8
Tobia Tobia
70T7
Master2Nena
25T1
JJ1986 JJ1986
50T3
ferguson
60T4
Grrr Grrr
73T4
Young_Jedi
100T7
Madeline Madeline
0T1
KombatRock KombatRock
78T7
Frosty Frosty
55T4
chaosxkitten chaosxkitten
32T2
TripleSH TripleSH
65T5
kafka1325 kafka1325
61T6
BaileyUNC02
50T2
comanchex
44T1
goran
47T3
gelfling
90T7
peekingpanda peekingpanda
20T2
PassTheSalt PassTheSalt
97T10
kdykema82
60T2
Nevermore Nevermore
70T6
Nanarama Nanarama
60T4
theriley
50T2
Bluladder
75T5
filmcricket
71T8
hotdishtv hotdishtv ()
100T10
8raz 8raz
64T4
momothepeach momothepeach
58T4
Gody85 Gody85
40T4
Sandstorm Sandstorm
80T6
Riel
80T6
PeregrinVelo PeregrinVelo
36T2
adoongdong
75T5
WaitingScene WaitingScene
34T2
DTI
63T2
BeeDub BeeDub
80T4
msweller msweller
60T2
Kusanagi Kusanagi
75T6
Icarus Icarus
75T6
Remus is the hero of this film which nicely mixes animation with live action. He is the most interesting and complex character, and in spite of the over-the-top down home feel to the African-American characters, they are all more sympathetic than any of the white characters save the child. In terms of narrative, it's definitely simplistic, but the animated sequences are inventive and the film contains numerous moments that kids will love. A solid Disney classic.
critickerlan
94T9
Political Political
60T6
ScrumYummy
67T5
soothsayer
43T3
shyfidelity
70T6
aerrich
60T7
Warchild
80T5
Entertaining, love the songs.
avgcrtckr avgcrtckr
51T5
indifferenti indifferenti
6T2
clayj41 clayj41
76T7
Kublai_Khan Kublai Khan
17T2
Aylmer
90T10
psych0naut psych0naut (The Socialist Standard)
40T2
Zodoto Zodoto
75T4
Dimentia Dimentia
55T3
The film's fatal flaw is that it's boring (excepting the animated sequences). It's not half as awful as its infamous reputation implies - its rosy viewpoints of Reconstruction-era Georgia are pretty cringeworthy, but not outright racist. (The Tar Baby thing is from African-American folklore, it's not exactly a racial slur) James Baskett is very, very good at what he does though.
filman7
99T9
The animated sequences and the relationship between Driscoll's Johnny and Baskett's Uncle Remus are the strong points in a film of pure brilliance.
moviesnmore
98T9
pomattovich
90T8
chiphall72
62T4
tma1 tma1
50T3
Maybe I'm too old to enjoy it, but I found it pretty boring. The mix of live-action and animation was well done. A good theme song. That's about it.
TheOnionRing
77T6
gdog13cavs
65T9
DocBrowne
74T6
kyleloomis kyle.loomis
4T5
Criminal5 Alex Watkins
60T2
Zippity doo dah, zippity aye/ My oh my what a wonderful day/ Here in the south whites give me no pay/ Zippity doo dah, zippity aye.
Sheldrake Sheldrake
50T4
dagda2
88T8
WilliamOTyle
80T8
giska giska
25T1
dr_radical dr. radical
32T1
miss_jesus miss jesus
27T1
The cartoons are as much fun as any classic Disney, but the amount of racist content in the film is unbelievable, from the tar baby to the depiction of Uncle Remus, and right on into the overarching "moral." The child actors are also far from appealing. The best thing about this film was the "Aunt Jemima's Mash Liquor" parody on SNL a few years ago.
dissidentdov
15T1
tielardurdin
30T1
ecalder ecalder
66T7
pyrosexual pyrosexual
75T4
Morrisseyfan
40T2
arcane369
75T5
moeta2
85T6
SirStuckey SirStuckey
35T2
Mostly boring as the stakes were that a kid was getting bullied by two other scrubs and his mom thought an old guy telling him stories was the root of his problems. The controversy around it makes sense but it feels like inadvertent tone-deafness than malicious racism. Since I had to watch a dookie quality version on youtube I didn't get to enjoy the alleged great animation. The ride sucks too by the way. Who wants to be wet all day and walk around?
RNG
48T5
allisoncm allisoncm
70T7
IMDb_byvotes IMDb-byvotes
74T7
Travisbickle Travisbickle
60T2
10kfilms
60T6
gtrmp
70T6
auhasarderik auhasarderik
70T6
screentime
56T3
helfen419 helfen419
68T4
Harsh
babamots babamots
60T4
Definitely a child-oriented film; not being in the target demographic, I was predictably unimpressed. However, Remus's soothing voice got me through as I watched out for racism. White characters' words are accepted like orders, but Remus is such a clear hero that the message seemed to even out.
bruinsfan bruinsfan
83T7
MentalCritic MentalCritic
64T5
Nick_C Nick C.
86T3
Good story, but the only three things I really praise are the animation, James Baskket's performance, and the main song.
eriond
100T10
dognamedfrog
50T2
kogepanic nosyparker
70T7
Average Tier 5.08 from 199 Rankings rss