sebby wrote:
-The male protagonists are among the most likeable in film history.
-Time travel -- I am simply a sucker for it. We all have plot-devices, actors, locales, etc., that, when present in a movie, make us like it more. Time travel is one for me.
-The meticulous re-creation and also lampooning of the Pop side of the American 1950's. Love it.
-Crispin Glover.
-Excellent soundtrack.
-Nostalgia (films like BTTF, Ghostbusters, E.T., etc., evoke the time in my life when I first fell in love with movies, so naturally they get a critical bump from me for no reason other than that).
-There is literally no scene in the movie that, to me, is superfluous or unentertaining. I have viewed very few movies about which I could reflect back upon and make this statement. Few films are able to truly lift me away from reality to a cognitive locale where my only focus is the story being told on the screen in front of me. Back to the Future does this.
Fair enough. I actually agree with all your subjective points; yes, the soundtrack is awesome, Crispin Glover is hilarious, the male protagonists are cool, so is the 1950's setting, and it was edited superbly.
I guess for me it was a cool movie I saw when I was 12, but it didn't stand out more than a number of other good action comedies of that period. And in fact, I thought something like "Ghostbusters" was way funnier and more memorable, and I watched both films around the same time.
Part of me thinking it's overrated is also due to the non-stop praise for "Back to the Future". There was all sorts of press/media coverage of its 25th anniversary, video game releases, and many people gushing it's "one of the greatest films...ever!"