Thank you for your reply. I admit I'am a bit torn on this one.
Because on the one hand there are very good arguments (see the discussion linked above) for tweaking the math by distributing the weight differently (and I agree that it would have to be done on both ends).
On the other hand, however, it's attractive how criticker is pretty straightforward without all the hocus-pocus of seemingly arbitrary tweaks (think IMDb's undisclosed calculations for their "weighted average").
So it's a tough call. I don't know.
However, what would definitely be a good idea (and certainly much less controversial) is to add a way for users to discover other users sharing your absolute favourite films – as they won't necessarily be among your best TCIs.
I'll add that as a separate feature idea here:
show users who love your top films
