amerigo

amerigo
Member Since
07 Jul 2007
N/A
TCI
3082
ratings
0
collections
36
Recent ratings
1345
Minireviews
850
Starred reviews
36
Recent ratings
1345
Minireviews
850
Starred reviews
Bio: My film rating scale: if it's over 80--it's a damned good movie; if it's between 80-70 it's either notably flawed or one of those 'different strokes for different folks' movies; if it's between 70-60 it's still enjoyable and/or has some artistic merit; if it's below 50 it's inexcusable, utter crap.
Featured Reviews
79 62%
Hokum
Hokum (2026) - Rated 11 May 2026
McCarthy is a frustrating film-maker. He clearly has the eye for haunting cinematography, a refined talent for building tension and, on occasion, executes legitimately creepy set pieces. I'm not sure why after a solidly good Oddity, he ended up with this rambling, often boring yarn, with glaringly flat characters? I mean if you get past the cliches and the unengaging narrative it's not bad... but can we just have a moratorium on the witch and vampire movies? Please, we've had enough!
86 90%
Weapons
Weapons (2025) - Rated 23 Aug 2025
It wears its Hereditary influences on its sleeve and while it leans into Ari Aster's offbeat dark humor on occasion, it stays taut throughout. It really nails the recipe that made the best of 80s horror so unique and it does so without pandering to 80s aesthetics (cough cough Longlegs). It's thematic nods to contemporary American small town politics is not overly overt, which only enhances the sense of immersion. A very significant improvement over the frustrartingly unfocused Barbarian.
74 34%
Heretic
Heretic (2024) - Rated 30 May 2025
A poor man's Red State that holds one's attention only due to the quality of the acting. The first act is interesting enough, but it feels like the scriptwriters didn't really know where to go with the material--how to make it SCARY horror? So it meanders through horror tropes in the outdated postmodernist way: by hiding in layers of meta-irony and riffing off Wikipedia articles. They had a good hook, but just wasted the idea by thinking the film needed to be like Saw to be taken seriously.