Smile 2
This review contains spoilers
As someone who liked the first movie, I also enjoyed the sequel—though I still can't decide which one I prefer. In the first, not knowing the creature's nature created tension; in this one, we already know what’s going on, so the element of surprise is gone. But Smile 2 shines in other areas that might make it even better. First off: Naomi Scott carries this film. Like, to the point where I wouldn’t be surprised if she needed physical therapy for back pain. What Max Verstappen did for Red Bull in F1 this year, Naomi does for Smile 2. Supporting cast? Practically invisible. ⚠️ Spoilers & non-spoilers mixed below. You've been warned. The movie runs long for a horror flick, which leads to some pacing issues. You get stretches where nothing happens, and others where jump scares fly at you nonstop. Still, even during the quiet parts, the demon’s nature makes you anticipate that someone’s going to flash that creepy grin at any moment—so the tension never really fades. That said, I think the whole hallucination concept is pushed too far this time. In the first movie, even when the afflicted saw hallucinations, their reactions affected the real world—others could see them acting erratically. That was part of the demon's tactic: isolating its victims by making them look insane. In Smile 2, though, the second half is almost entirely hallucination. Ever since that dance scene in her house, nothing is real. Which raises a huge plot hole: if she's hallucinating all this, how did she make it to that concert venue? No one noticed she was out of her mind? Not one person said, “Yo, she’s not okay”? That’s the biggest logical flaw for me. Aside from that, most hallucinations do have clues. For example: when her friend Gemma appears, we realize she’s not real. Skye’s mom doesn't respond to her presence, even though she told Skye earlier to reconnect with her. Gemma also never replies to texts. And in the care home scene, the driver completely ignores Gemma when she’s threatened with a gun. Five minutes later, we get full confirmation she’s a hallucination. Fun fact: the guy playing Skye’s creepy dead boyfriend at the reception? That’s Jack Nicholson’s son. Apparently the director asked him, “Can you grin like your dad did in The Shining?” And he said, “I’ll try.” He nailed it. Dude looks terrifying. In the first movie, I remember hallucinations being actual people—just perceived differently by the cursed person. Like, they were there, just with weird facial expressions. In this one, it’s a mix. Some are real (like the little girl at the fan event), but others—like the creepy nude guy and the dance team—are full-on hallucinations. That shift in logic makes the rules feel looser. I get the sense they gave the demon new powers to make up for the lack of mystery in the sequel. About that guy who knows the demon’s nature (I’m calling him Dr. Taub because I only remember him from House)—I believe their conversation at the bar was real. The constant phone calls Skye gets during it are hallucinations meant to distract her. Dr. Taub doesn’t even flinch while her phone keeps ringing. The demon sees him as a threat and tries to derail the conversation, successfully. She panics and runs, giving up her last shot at salvation. That moment marks her full surrender. In the final sequence, Skye kills herself in front of thousands of people—effectively making all of them potential victims. Based on the first movie’s rules, I doubt the curse will spread to everyone at once. More likely, the demon will go after the most traumatized people first, one by one. So instead of mass hysteria, we’ll probably see a string of suicides week after week. Still, I wish we got more lore this time. I wanted to learn about the demon’s origins—how long it’s been haunting people, where it came from. Also, the whole "stop your heart and revive yourself to break the curse" thing introduced by Taub? Totally dropped. I assume they’re saving that for the next film. So is Smile 2 better than the first? Hard to say. Each has its strengths. But considering horror is a tough genre, and this is only the director’s second film (his debut was Smile), he’s doing a stellar job maintaining quality. With the right lead—someone Naomi Scott-level—they’ve got a real shot at turning this into the Conjuring of the 2020s.
Mini Review: As someone who liked the first movie, I also enjoyed the sequel—though I still can't decide which one I prefer. In the first, not knowing the creature's nature created tension; in this one, we already know what’s going on, so the element of surprise is gone. But Smile 2 shines in other areas that might make it even better. First off: Naomi Scott carries this film. Like, to the point where I wouldn’t be surprised if she needed physical...
More Reviews of Smile 2
decatur555
The sequel surpasses the first, delivering a deeper exploration of the protagonist's growing madness. The horror atmosphere intensifies, complemented by well-executed gore scene...
halwf
This was miles better than the first one. I kind of wish the first one never came out so this made a bigger splash. I thought this was really enjoyable. Great lead performance. ...
floucc
Jag när Raúl Castillo: 😯
Jag när Dylan Gelula: 😯😭🤠
Det var kul att de två var med! Tyvärr så var de aldrig i bild samtidigt… (Cooper Raiff)
Min korta beskrivning av den h...
See all 4 reviews of Smile 2
Watch the Trailer
