An American in Paris

geniasis
Review by
11 Aug 2025
Not That Hot
37th percentile
79
An American in Paris unfolds as a dazzling spectacle of color, choreography, and song, yet beneath its glittering veneer lies a more profound struggle—one that speaks to the existential condition itself. Jerry Mulligan, the American painter adrift in postwar Paris, embodies the individual striving to give form to his freedom. He paints, he loves, he dances, but always he finds himself entangled in webs spun by others’ expectations—patrons, lovers, rivals.

The musical’s triumphs are evident: Gershwin’s score shimmers with vitality, and the climactic ballet pulses with surreal exuberance, embodying the dreamlike possibility of transcending one’s limits. Yet, this very exuberance reveals an incompleteness. Sartre reminds us that desire, when bound to the gaze of others, risks becoming a prison. Jerry and Lise are radiant in their yearning, but their love, subject to social obligations and rival suitors, cannot exist in pure freedom. What dazzles us, therefore, is not fulfillment but the spectacle of perpetual striving.

In this way, the film becomes more than romance—it is a parable of human existence. We are condemned to create meaning in the face of absurdity, and An American in Paris shows this through dance and song rather than words. Its joy is undeniable, but joy here is not the negation of despair. It is the flickering light cast upon it, never erasing the shadow. The film achieves greatness not in resolving tension, but in exposing the beautiful impossibility of resolution.
Mini Review: Beneath its luminous choreography, the film reveals not merely romance but the restless search for authenticity. Beauty dazzles, yet the characters’ passions remain unfinished, circling freedom they cannot wholly claim. It is a joyous spectacle shadowed by the absurd—delightful, but never complete.