Frankenstein
Studying Frankenstein for GCSE (including a comparative study of Blade Runner, of course) hard-wired a very specific creature into my head, so I went into del Toro’s version quietly braced for disappointment. What surprised me was how often it lined up with the book I remember: no comedy bolts through the neck, just a stitched-together body that looks genuinely painful to inhabit, shuffling through damp streets and candlelit rooms like something from a feverish painting.
The production design, costumes and make-up are superb – mildew, velvet and scar tissue you can almost smell – which is why the more obvious CGI flourishes feel like a step down. Whenever the film leans on pixels rather than prosthetics, it loses a bit of that bruised, tactile magic. Del Toro’s direction is as sure-footed as you’d hope: long, gliding moves, a fondness for shadows and water, and a habit of framing the creature as victim first, monster second.
Oscar Isaac plays Victor as a wounded romantic slowly curdling into obsession; Jacob Elordi’s creature gets a beautifully modulated arc – confused child, furious outcast, tragic adult, sometimes in a single scene. Mia Goth makes Elizabeth more than just a doomed fiancée, hinting at a life and intelligence the story keeps pushing to the margins. Even the arms-dealer benefactor and household hangers-on feel like people rather than just plot furniture.
The nesting-doll structure and parental responsibility are intact, but Victor’s abusive backstory, the arms-dealer patron and Elizabeth’s altered fate tilt it towards father–son dynamics and militarism. A few speeches spell out what the images already told us, yet overall this feels less like a museum piece and more like a properly alive adaptation
The production design, costumes and make-up are superb – mildew, velvet and scar tissue you can almost smell – which is why the more obvious CGI flourishes feel like a step down. Whenever the film leans on pixels rather than prosthetics, it loses a bit of that bruised, tactile magic. Del Toro’s direction is as sure-footed as you’d hope: long, gliding moves, a fondness for shadows and water, and a habit of framing the creature as victim first, monster second.
Oscar Isaac plays Victor as a wounded romantic slowly curdling into obsession; Jacob Elordi’s creature gets a beautifully modulated arc – confused child, furious outcast, tragic adult, sometimes in a single scene. Mia Goth makes Elizabeth more than just a doomed fiancée, hinting at a life and intelligence the story keeps pushing to the margins. Even the arms-dealer benefactor and household hangers-on feel like people rather than just plot furniture.
The nesting-doll structure and parental responsibility are intact, but Victor’s abusive backstory, the arms-dealer patron and Elizabeth’s altered fate tilt it towards father–son dynamics and militarism. A few speeches spell out what the images already told us, yet overall this feels less like a museum piece and more like a properly alive adaptation
Mini Review: Studying Frankenstein for GCSE hard-wired a very specific creature into my head, and del Toro’s version comes closer to it than any I’ve seen: no comedy bolts, just a stitched-together body that looks painful to inhabit. Gorgeous production design and strong turns from Oscar Isaac, Jacob Elordi and Mia Goth carry it, even if some CGI and on-the-nose speeches blunt the impact. A genuinely alive adaptation.
More Reviews of Frankenstein
titireviewer
Eu falo português sim, mas gostaria que falássemos em inglês
Começando por uma pequena brincadeira, da neta da Maria Gladys, Mia Goth finalmente está em uma grande produção ...
Melleloaf
It is a shame to say that this was an utter disappointment.
I truly wanted to love this film, as I'm a big fan of Frankenstein and gothic literature in general. I put a lot o...
glumpy_99
I feel like this is the version of FRANKENSTEIN that Branagh wanted to make: a splashy, bold and at times genuinely moving version of this tale, that brings a laser focus to the...
ccslicker
Inside this not very good 150 minute film is a very good 95 minute film.
The good film would start once the Creature had come to life and linger longer with him as he...
The good film would start once the Creature had come to life and linger longer with him as he...
decatur555
I’d been hearing a lot of negativity about Guillermo del Toro’s Frankenstein even before watching it, and yet it won me over more than most modern adaptations. Even more than th...
See all 11 reviews of Frankenstein
Watch the Trailer
