Human Desire
I keep thinking of Human Desire as a film noir in a toxic relationship with a melodrama. On paper it’s Zola via Renoir, but Lang sands off some of La Bête Humaine’s madness and leaves something softer and more domestic, tidier psychologically. I was curious, but never quite gripped, for the first hour.
For most of the film Ford and Grahame feel oddly muted, like big stars parked in a story that hasn’t decided what to do with them. It’s only in the third act that they finally spark: Ford’s quiet, depressive railway man suddenly feels like a person rather than a type, and Grahame’s trapped wife becomes properly, thrillingly opaque. Broderick Crawford is a convincingly pathetic brute throughout, lumbering around with the threat of violence hanging off him.
The train sequences are the real draw — long, hypnotic runs of steel and motion — but the finale ducks the novel’s nihilism, so well captured in La Bête Humaine, without finding a sharper alternative. Flawed and frustrating, yet it lingers more than you’d think.
For most of the film Ford and Grahame feel oddly muted, like big stars parked in a story that hasn’t decided what to do with them. It’s only in the third act that they finally spark: Ford’s quiet, depressive railway man suddenly feels like a person rather than a type, and Grahame’s trapped wife becomes properly, thrillingly opaque. Broderick Crawford is a convincingly pathetic brute throughout, lumbering around with the threat of violence hanging off him.
The train sequences are the real draw — long, hypnotic runs of steel and motion — but the finale ducks the novel’s nihilism, so well captured in La Bête Humaine, without finding a sharper alternative. Flawed and frustrating, yet it lingers more than you’d think.
Mini Review: Human Desire feels like noir in a bad relationship with a melodrama. Lang smooths out La Bête Humaine’s madness into something softer and more domestic. Ford and Grahame are oddly muted until the third act, when they finally spark to life, while Broderick Crawford lumbers convincingly as a pathetic brute. The train sequences are hypnotic, but the ending ducks the novel’s nihilism without finding anything sharper.
Watch the Trailer
