A Matter of Life and Death

nickismydog
Review by
15 Nov 2026
Awesome
97th percentile
100
It’s insane to think this was made in 1946, and it feels not just way ahead of its time, but outside of time completely. For such a seemingly simple romance/comedy film, it’s so layered and has so many powerful ideas going on. For starters, it’s really funny, wildly entertaining, and endlessly watchable. The plot itself is captivating and you’re not bored for a minute of the film. Every element of it- the opening, Heaven, the doctor stuff, the trial, etc. I really like the ambiguity between fantasy and reality, which makes the film serve as commentary on both bureaucracy and systems, and survivor’s guilt (which is a major theme of the film imo) and war trauma. It has powerful themes of love too, and I really like how it’s portrayed in this film. It’s also remarkably yet somewhat quietly progressive and internationalist. It strongly critiques British imperial history, and gives centuries of genuine grievances, yet the film still suggests shared humanity outweighs national history, and shows how nations change and even appear somewhat artificial- like when the modern American defence is called up, and you see people from all over the world. And the very year after the end of a nationalist war, it says that what matters isn’t Britain, isn’t glory, isn’t revenge, it’s individual and common human life. I like its life-affirming message too. On top of what I’ve already said, ultimately it rejects Heaven- often claimed as the ultimate goal- for life. And visually, it’s absolutely gorgeous, and extremely impressive. Unbelievable for 1946 and still beautiful for today. It also has a certain charm and familiarity to it, that makes it feel comfortable in a way.
Mini Review: It’s insane to think this was made in 1946, and it feels not just way ahead of its time, but outside of time completely. For such a seemingly simple romance/comedy film, it’s so layered and has so many powerful ideas going on. For starters, it’s really funny, wildly entertaining, and endlessly watchable. The plot itself is captivating and you’re not bored for a minute of the film. Every element of it- the opening, Heaven, the doctor stuff, the trial, etc. I really like the ambiguity bet...
Watch the Trailer