Melancholia
“You should be happy”
“I’m happy that you’re happy”
Holy shit man the amount of times I must’ve said this over the years
You can really tell this was made by someone who’s dealt with depression, because this is one of the most real and accurate depictions of depression I’ve seen.
Justine, through Kirsten Dunst’s brilliant performance, nails it the entire way through. And the central plot reinforces this: with the end of the world, Claire becomes extremely anxious, unravels completely. In contrast, the severely depressed Justine is calm, practical, almost peaceful. That inversion seems absurd but makes complete sense when you consider that for a depressed person, the world is already empty, the future is already closed. The apocalypse doesn’t completely change the outside world for her, it just makes it reflect her internal one. "The Earth is evil. We don't need to grieve for it."
More broadly, Von Trier depicts depression so well because he understands it isn’t just crying or being sad. It’s emotional flatness, it’s being unable to move, unable to feel, unable to want anything, unable to imagine anything. Her being unable to just step into a bath might seem so strange to most, but it’s such an accurate portrayal of how depression can make you feel. She complains things are feeling heavy, she can barely walk. Lots of people might think this is a metaphor, but I think many depressed people can recognise this as very literal. The physical is so often separated from the emotional, but depression literally drags you down physically.
And with the horse: there’s no physical barrier, nothing visibly stopping it from crossing the bridge and moving forward. To most, it’s “just go”- but, no matter how hard or how many times she tries, she physically cannot.
Other people’s attitudes towards her are also so accurate for a depressed person’s experience- people complaining she’s ruining things, interpreting her as lazy, as selfish, as having a bad attitude, etc. They evaluate behaviour not capacity. And the amount of times people told her to just “be happy”, or “why aren’t you happy?”…
The fact the film opens with the ending is just brilliant too. Because there’s no suspense, depression removes the suspense from life entirely. You already know how it ends, you’re just watching and waiting- exactly how depression feels. And the actual ending, there’s just something so beautiful about it. And compassionate.
Mini Review: “You should be happy”
“I’m happy that you’re happy”
Holy shit man the amount of times I must’ve said this over the years
You can really tell this was made by someone who’s dealt with depression, because this is one of the most real and accurate depictions of depression I’ve seen.
Justine, through Kirsten Dunst’s brilliant performance, nails it the entire way through. And the central plot reinforces this: with the end of the world, Claire becomes extremely anxious, unravels completely...
More Reviews of Melancholia
Watch the Trailer
