Reds

nickismydog
Review by
15 Nov 2026
Awesome
97th percentile
100
I was fully absorbed and constantly engaged for the entire 195 minutes. What a film. What captivated me most were the politics, especially everything in Russia, the best parts of the film. Reed arriving in Russia, the hope of the Revolution, the sense that history was genuinely open and alive- I loved all of it. It was amazing to see the Russian Revolution portrayed on film in a way that neither romanticises nor demonises it, but instead presents it as a complex and living historical reality. The film is remarkably sympathetic to socialism and the Revolution, but it is also surprisingly balanced and politically honest. It presents the critical perspective through Goldman- starvation, repression, centralisation- but it doesn't simply stop there. It also provides the context for why these things happened: the invasion, the blockade, the immense difficulties facing the new regime, and the sense of an international revolution being strangled in its cradle. The film acknowledges both the hope and the tragedy of the Revolution. It also shows signs of its degeneration, particularly when Zinoviev replaces “class war” with “holy war” to better appeal to local people. And I can’t lie, the swelling of emotion when *The Internationale* played was incredible, and the October Revolution sequence was amazing and so hopeful. In general it was so cool seeing all of this on screen- the Revolution, the Bolsheviks, the workers, etc. Great design overall. What I also appreciated was how lived and real everything felt. The revolution and the ideology aren’t presented as abstract ideas or slogans, but as something people actually experience. They are messy, exhausting, inspiring, attractive, and difficult. The film feels grounded and human throughout, both politically and visually, as the overall design is fantastic. The romance is excellent as well. Reed is a fantastic character- charismatic, compelling, and very well acted- and I found his story genuinely moving. I got pretty emotional both when he and Louise reunited near the end and when he died. Louise is also very strong as a character. She's never reduced to being just a love interest, but has her own journey of self-definition as she struggles to reconcile political commitment, artistic independence, romantic fulfilment, and personal freedom. The relationship itself is messy and constantly tested, but that only makes it more affecting. In the end, the film affirms the relationship despite all the strain placed upon it. One of the film's most interesting ideas is the relationship between the political and the personal. It explores how someone can simultaneously be a revolutionary committed to a collective cause and still remain an individual with personal desires, relationships, and struggles. I think that's one of the film's central theses, and it's something I found both powerful and deeply meaningful and personal. Alongside this, Eugene's cynicism is contrasted with the idealism of the other characters, and I think the film ultimately comes down on the side of hope. The film is also notable for how politically honest it is. Communist beliefs are presented as actual beliefs held by intelligent, sincere people rather than as caricatures, which is surprisingly rare- especially for a massive Reagan-era Hollywood epic. Whether one agrees with them or not, the film treats them seriously. I also really liked the witnesses. They give the film a documentary-like quality and make the history feel tangible and human. They remind us that history is made by real people, and that memory itself remains alive, shaped by those who lived through events. Visually, the film isn't flashy, but there are some gorgeous shots throughout. The cinematography is simple and effective, helping reinforce the realism and grounded feeling of the entire film. What also stayed with me a lot was the film's sense of hope. It captures a period when profound change seemed genuinely possible. At the same time, it never suggests that history is inevitable. The revolutionaries repeatedly face defeat, isolation, repression, factionalism, and mistakes. The film's optimism comes not from certainty, but from commitment despite uncertainty. Its message isn't that history is automatically on anyone's side; it's that meaningful change only happens because people act as though a better future is possible, even when success is far from guaranteed. That perspective feels refreshing in an era often defined by cynicism and hopelessness, in a world where change frankly feels impossible and hope, meaningless. There's something both inspiring and melancholy about looking back at a time when change felt possible, a moment of hope captured and frozen in this film.
Mini Review: I was fully absorbed and constantly engaged for the entire 195 minutes. What a film. What captivated me most were the politics, especially everything in Russia, the best parts of the film. Reed arriving in Russia, the hope of the Revolution, the sense that history was genuinely open and alive- I loved all of it. It was amazing to see the Russian Revolution portrayed on film in a way that neither romanticises nor demonises it, but instead presents it as a complex and living historical reali...
Watch the Trailer