Rogue One: A Star Wars Story
Very fun, watchable, and entertaining. People complain about uneven pacing or a slow first half, but I really don’t feel it.
The planets are awesome, with Jedha standing out in particular, and Scarif also being very cool.
The cinematography is fantastic, with absolutely gorgeous visuals throughout.
The film’s depiction of the Rebellion is more morally compromised and grounded, and Saw’s group is especially interesting, and the paranoia is interesting. The Empire feels more real, grounded, systemic, and bureaucratic rather than cartoonishly evil, which overall makes the film feel more grounded and realistic. I also like how it focuses on more ordinary and everyday people, which makes it feel very grounded and distinct from typical Star Wars.
The Death Star itself is intimidating and genuinely scary.
There are some great quotes and some good dialogue. “Rebellions are built on hope” is powerful. “Can you stand to see the Imperial flag reign across the galaxy?” “It’s not a problem if you don’t look up” really reflects political ignorance, blindness, and apoliticism.
Sometimes the film is a bit too heavy on nostalgia and fanservice. However, everything involving Vader is genuinely very cool. He is very intimidating when speaking to Krennic, and that scene is visually gorgeous. The hallway scene is also genuinely awesome, again with gorgeous visuals, and it makes him feel incredibly intimidating.
In terms of characters, I really like Cassian as a very interesting character who is morally ambiguous, pragmatic, and grounded, and who is definitely deepened by Andor. Krennic is also an interesting, unique, and genuinely compelling antagonist. I like Jyn as well, but she’s not a very deep or extensively explored character. Her arc is good, but she could have been deeper or more internally explored. The other characters are conceptually interesting, but they are quite archetypal and underdeveloped, so you don’t care as much about them, which makes their deaths less impactful.
While the film does include politics and complicates them more than, for example, the OT, they still remain somewhat simplified.
The third act is great, exciting, fun, and entertaining. The space battle and the Battle of Scarif are both highlights, although the corvette manoeuvre is admittedly a bit stupid.
I really like the central theme of hope, and the ending, where the heroes die, the Death Star is completed, but a sliver of hope remains, is great.
Mini Review: Very fun, watchable, and entertaining. People complain about uneven pacing or a slow first half, but I really don’t feel it.
The planets are awesome, with Jedha standing out in particular, and Scarif also being very cool.
The cinematography is fantastic, with absolutely gorgeous visuals throughout.
The film’s depiction of the Rebellion is more morally compromised and grounded, and Saw’s group is especially interesting, and the paranoia is interesting. The Empire feels more real, grou...
More Reviews of Rogue One: A Star Wars Story
sniffly
rewatched after finishing andor (really, really, really good) so having to see him take a backseat to jyn threw me off at first.
some of the best visuals and action in the se...
hotsake
This is a hard movie to rate. It wasn't as good as I'd hoped but at the same time it wasn't as bad as I expected. The side characters were great and fun as was the robot for the...
Watch the Trailer
