Star Wars: Episode III - Revenge of the Sith
Very fun, entertaining, watchable, with some great stuff going on but also plagued by poor writing decisions.
One thing that sucks is that the opening crawl says “there are heroes on both sides. Evil is everywhere”, yet every Separatist we see is pure evil, we only see Republic heroes.
Padmé’s character is completely massacred. We lose the strongheaded, proactive idealist from the previous two films, who was a major protagonist in each. Instead, she’s exclusively reactive, and spends most of the time crying and telling Anakin how much she loves him- all the while doing nothing as the Republic she dedicated her life to crumbles. She turns from a real character into a crutch for Anakin’s arc. I do still like her political tirades and dialogue, but that’s kind of it.
Killing Dooku off so early was a terrible decision, leaving him underdeveloped, removing one of the most interesting characters and elements of the Separatists, and replacing him with a new unknown and fairly one-note villain, Grievous. Dooku could’ve added real complexity, weight, and moral ambiguity to the film, and deepened the Separatists further.
Grievous himself is inconsistent. A coward who uses his droids to fight Kenobi early in the film before fleeing, he later chooses to fight Kenobi (a renowned Jedi & duelist) directly on Utapau rather than having the hundreds of droids surrounding him fire. In fact, on Utapau, Grievous first sends Magnaguards to kill him, meaning he’s okay leaving it up to the droids, but when they fall, he chooses to do one on one. And that decision from Kenobi to drop in there was also moronic. The duel itself is flashy and is fairly entertaining but the stakes and involvement feel much lower since we hardly know Grievous.
The Windu-Palpatine duel is very disappointing. Poorly choreographed, very awkward, Palpatine’s yell/spin is hilarious, and the others fall immediately.
Of course, the monumental Clone Wars, which should be incredibly significant, are kind of just glossed over. Overall, there’s a lot going on in this film, maybe too much- things move too quickly, have very little time to breathe or develop, especially Anakin’s fall, which feels incredibly rushed. One moment he saves Palpatine out of desperation, which is understandable, and the scene paralleling him and Padmé worked very well. The next, he regrets it immediately and feels very conflicted, and Palpatine literally tells him that he does not ACTUALLY know how to prevent death! But this lasts only a mere second, and in the very next scene, he pledges himself fully to Palpatine and, in the following scene, he commits genocide and massacres children. Anakin also knows fully well that the Jedi attacked Palpatine because he was a Sith, and know he believes the Jedi will seize power and attack the Senate, and chooses to genocide them.
The overly long rescue mission is has very little to do with the rest of the film, and Palpatine’s plan is… weird, completely risking his life so that maybe Anakin will kill Dooku.
Padmé’s death is so dumb.
It’s deeply engaging, fun, entertaining, and watchable. The CGI is quite good and overall it’s visually gorgeous, even if the camerawork remains flat. Some strong visual storytelling throughout, and great use of shadow. The visuals are genuinely amazing, it’s a gorgeous film. A brilliant score as well. While there’s lots of terrible dialogue, there’s also some pretty quippy and light dialogue. Regardless of the quality, the dialogue has lots of charm. Palpatine’s manipulative dialogue is quite good.
It DOES have lots of great themes, even if they feel less sophisticated than AOTC. Of course, the core of Anakin’s fall is fear of loss and inability to accept mortality. Anakin’s tragedy is that he does love Padmé, and tries saving her, but in doing so, he destroys everything, including her- which is genuinely tragic. However, despite it being great conceptually, it could’ve been better executed.
I also like the political themes, although again they feel less sophisticated than AOTC. The Republic isn’t conquered from the outside, but decays from the inside, with Palpatine using fear and war to seize emergency powers and democratically erect the Empire, showing how democracies become dictatorships through popular acceptance, not just brute force. And the Jedi fail from their own flaws. They fall institutionally because of their hubris and their absorption into the wartime state, becoming generals for the Republic, and Anakin falls in part due to their inability to understand him and their emotional repression.
Of course, we see how war complicates morality, especially as the Jedi increasingly compromise on their principles, choosing to spy on Palpatine, ready to kill him while unarmed, militarising, and discussing seizing power.
The film continues the prequels’ theme of mechanisation and industrialisation, as the film is dominated by artificial, mechanised landscapes, mirroring the Republic’s descent into the Empire and Anakin’s transformation into Vader.
Anakin and Obi-Wan are very charismatic, they have great chemistry, I love the two characters. I think Obi-Wan is a great character, I really like him- fatherly, compassionate, witty, smart- and Ewan McGregor is fantastic. Anakin’s character is charismatic and interesting, and I think Hayden portrays his internal conflict very well, but he isn’t always handled the best way. Similarly, the line delivery is often weak and wooden- which I blame on the dialogue and the directing, especially since the actors do much better when silent.
I think the film has a strong emotional core, with Anakin’s downfall, the personal and political tragedy, his attempts to save Padmé, and his fight with Obi-Wan. I do genuinely find Order 66 very sad and emotionally impactful, and it’s tragic to see all the world and people we enjoyed and had fun with for two and a half films crumble.
While Anakin’s tragic downfall is strong conceptually, I think it’s poorly executed, and his character is often unsympathetic. His complaint about not being a Master just comes off as whiny and entitled. He feels like he’s complaining about way too much, especially when he complains about Obi-Wan when we see their friendship and Obi-Wan’s respect and love for Anakin. His major redeeming quality is that he has some self-awareness, knowing he’s not what he should be. His emotional repression and isolation in AOTC made him cracking believable and understandable, while here, it really doesn’t seem as justified, as he’s much more emotionally connected and open, feels freer, and has more support.
I really like how dark it is, and I find the fact it ends with total collapse of essentially everything is extremely impactful and poignant- definitely my favourite part of the film, and what makes it stand out.
Palpatine is a compelling villain and his manipulations are interesting.
It feels more kinetic, energetic, and free-flowing than the previous two, not as wooden or repressed.
It’s got the fun Star Wars feel, and it’s deeply nostalgic to me- it was my favourite film for years.
I think it rushes through the first half, but the second half is particularly poignant and impactful- Order 66, the Temple massacre, the Anakin-Kenobi duel, the ending.
Despite the flaws, the tragedy is extremely poignant, the character arcs are impactful, the characters themselves are charming, I’m in love with its grand operatic scale and ambition, I love how dark it is. The visuals are gorgeous and the score is incredible.
It does a good job wrapping up the prequels and setting the pieces for the original trilogy- although, again, Padmé is where it stumbles, as it tries to kill her off to complete Anakin’s tragedy and awkwardly conflicts with Leia sharing memories of her mother.
The ending is fantastic. The tragic images of Padmé’s funeral and then of Vader, before switching to Leia being delivered to her foster parents, and Luke being held by his as they stare at the twin suns setting- a gorgeous image, and ending the prequels with a tinge of hope amidst the despair.
Overall, it feels like it sacrifices some of the slowness, thematic depth, and complexity of AOTC to make an engaging and fast-moving blockbuster, while also trying to be a political and mythic tragedy- and it’s definitely a tragic film, in how people can destroy something by trying to save it. Very strong ideas, occasionally bogged down by writing and execution. I also think it could’ve gone deeper with its political themes and ideas. I think it’s a very dark and heartbreaking ending, which is one of its strongest elements. I have very conflicted feelings about this film, because it genuinely has some of the highest highs of the whole saga, but also has many significant lows.
And I greatly appreciate its ambition and mythic scale, thematic darkness, political tragedy, and emotional ideas.
Mini Review: Very fun, entertaining, watchable, with some great stuff going on but also plagued by poor writing decisions.
One thing that sucks is that the opening crawl says “there are heroes on both sides. Evil is everywhere”, yet every Separatist we see is pure evil, we only see Republic heroes.
Padmé’s character is completely massacred. We lose the strongheaded, proactive idealist from the previous two films, who was a major protagonist in each. Instead, she’s exclusively reactive, and sp...
More Reviews of Star Wars: Episode III - Revenge of the Sith
sniffly
is it Actually Good? no not really, but it's impossible to separate watching this now from all the time i spent watching Clone Wars and all the times I rewatched the DVD of this...
titireviewer
Sim voltei para as opiniões do famoso Star Wars, mas ainda confesso não gostar do primeiro, de lutas estrelares e um sistema político complicado, tem que gostar de temas do univ...
Malaki2008
Culminating the grand, tragic arc of a fallen democracy and the corruption of cinema’s most iconic villain, Star Wars: Episode III – Revenge of the Sith stands as a monumental a...
See all 4 reviews of Star Wars: Episode III - Revenge of the Sith
Watch the Trailer
