The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring

nickismydog
Review by
15 Nov 2026
Awesome
88th percentile
90
“There is only one Lord of the ring.” “You shall be the fellowship of the ring.” Two real lines of dialogue. Peak writing. Okay, I was wrong last time. This is an amazing film.  Practical, physical, feels real, and has a very strong aesthetic. And a wonderful, fantastical world that feels real- it feels like it has a history, like it’s existed long before this film and will continue long after- and carries you away, captures your imagination, and makes you inhabit it. It’s got a fantastic sense of wonder and fantasy which I just love, and beneath it all, there’s a nice feeling of friendship and warmth. It’s also remarkably sincere and committed to what it is. And the comedy contributes to the warmth, lightness, and fun, which are essential to preventing this film from becoming oppressively portentous.  Its leisurely pacing really contributes to that feeling of being in a world- making it feel like you’re living inside this world, wandering around it, and spending time with it. I also love the sublime in here. The film really is awe-inspiring, particularly because it gives you the time to look at things instead of breezing through them. The landscapes are fantastic and awe-inspiring, and create the feeling of a real journey, as well as giving each location a clearly distinctive character. The story is great. It really does feel like one big, epic adventure, while keeping a focus on the characters. Most of the characters are strong and easy to attach to, though not all are incredibly complex, and Boromir especially has a great arc. The Ring is fantastic, almost acting as a character, and serving as a powerful corrupting influence. I love Aragorn too, and Frodo is simple but likeable and human- a great hero’s journey archetype. Pippin and Merry are all right, Sam is a little plain in this one (but works as a friend and source of warmth for Frodo), Legolas is very wooden and flat (largely due to Bloom’s performance), and Gimli is meh- sometimes a bit annoying, as he’s basically just comic relief. But the overall group of the Fellowship is great. Great job with tone too. It starts warm, homely, and cozy, and gets much darker. You really feel like it’s an ordinary, cozy life that turns into a big epic adventure. I especially love the Nazgûl and their sequences, which really feel horror-like. There’s a great progression from the warmth and safety of the Shire into something increasingly frightening and dangerous. The wide shots, which are plentiful, really make it feel huge and important. Overall, the filmmaking and camerawork are very controlled yet wonderfully dynamic. The lighting especially is very expressive. And it’s always watchable and entertaining, with momentum and great tension. The music too is just phenomenal- sounds fantastic, conveys everything so well, and has a very distinct fantasy identity.
Mini Review: “There is only one Lord of the ring.” “You shall be the fellowship of the ring.” Two real lines of dialogue. Peak writing. Okay, I was wrong last time. This is an amazing film.  Practical, physical, feels real, and has a very strong aesthetic. And a wonderful, fantastical world that feels real- it feels like it has a history, like it’s existed long before this film and will continue long after- and carries you away, captures your imagination, and makes you inhabit it. It’s got a fanta...
Watch the Trailer