Don't Tell a Soul

nova-merollis
17 Nov 2026
Good
66th percentile
80
this is the most insane movie i’ve ever fucking seen. the performances are insane. this is such an interesting vignette in the lives of this family. matt’s gross hyperfixation with being gay and the weird homoerotic tension directed towards his younger brother really has me wondering what the father was doing at night, especially given the line “you gay? dad would be so proud.” because yes that could be ironic but the man was clearly an abusive alcoholic and typically a seventeen year old boy wouldn’t be so fixated on shit like that unless he either is gay or has been abused.  its also such an interesting thought experiment about what you would do if you were in those circumstances. also just the insane manipulation this poor boy was in the middle of from both sides, both by shitty people. one trying to act as a father figure to get what he wants, and one to play mind games with him to keep himself from getting in trouble. also upon him getting out, joey still clearly wants that father figure out of him to the point of asking him to go with him. and that man still manipulating him upon getting out talking about taking him hunting knowing his dad is dead and that he himself killed his own family. jesus christ.  this movie is so fucked up and layered and i will need to watch this again. the ending is a whole other beast i will have to watch again to fully dissect. tho i will say idk why the police didn’t call for backup but maybe that’s a tiny ass town thing. also the fucking fact that the mom killed her husband like fuck yes queen fucking shit. don’t take fucking nothing!!!!!!!!!!!!!!  and i will say i do honestly believe that matt is sorry. he grew up in a violent house and i really do think it took an insane wake up call for him to come back to reality. i really do hope for some kind of healing and some intense intense therapy for these goddamn people bc god matt is broken and joey is so desperately clinging onto any adult in hopes for a parental relationship.
Mini Review: this is the most insane movie i’ve ever fucking seen. the performances are insane. this is such an interesting vignette in the lives of this family. matt’s gross hyperfixation with being gay and the weird homoerotic tension directed towards his younger brother really has me wondering what the father was doing at night, especially given the line “you gay? dad would be so proud.” because yes that could be ironic but the man was clearly an abusive alcoholic and typically a seventeen year old boy...