The Thursday Murder Club

teylor
Review by
21 Feb 2026
Not Good
27th percentile
79
This review contains spoilers
​Logic and Plot Consistency: 1.1/1.5 Bogdan finding the body felt purely coincidental. Had that stroke of luck not occurred, the entire puzzle would have remained incomplete. ​Character Depth: 1.5/1.5 Each character had their own distinct personality, traits, and quirks. It was truly well-done, and they shared great chemistry. ​Subtext and Dialogue: 0.75/1 Due to the abundance of names and the overall complexity of the plot, I found myself genuinely confused in certain parts regarding what was happening. ​Atmosphere and World-building: 1/1 Extraordinary. The warmth and vibrancy depicted within a retirement home full of elderly people were beautiful. Excellent color palette. ​Atmospheric Fidelity: 1/1 ​Portrayal of Inner Layers: 0.6/1 To be honest, I couldn’t resonate with their internal emotions as deeply as you had described. ​Emotional Believability: 0.6/1 It was decent, but since the roles didn't necessarily demand "understated acting," no particular subtle performance stood out. ​Technical Execution: 0.8/1 There were moments where I felt lost, wondering, "Wait, what just happened?" or "What about the rest of the story?" ​Narrative Innovation: 0.3 A murder mystery solved by a group of non-professionals is a recurring trope. While some fresh "seasoning" was added here, the core concept remains familiar. ​Memorability: 0.3/0.5 Due to its high complexity—which is technically a strength of the story—my final sense of enjoyment was slightly diminished.
Mini Review: Vibrant atmosphere and great chemistry, but the plot relies on coincidence. High complexity and many names cause confusion, while the familiar trope lacks deep innovation. Though technically solid, the over-complication slightly diminishes the final enjoyment. Score: 7.95/10
Watch the Trailer