Carrie
This adaptation had a major problem before I even started watching it: I love Brian De Palma's 1976 film.
Any new version of Carrie therefore has to compete not only with a story I already know, but with an image of Carrie White that is almost impossible to separate from Sissy Spacek.
That is why I was surprised by how quickly this version drew me in.
Much of the credit goes to Summer H. Howell.
From the beginning, she has an innocence and vulnerability that make it extremely easy to care about Carrie. She does not simply feel “weird” because the story needs an outsider. She feels like a girl who has grown up isolated and badly equipped to deal with a world capable of extraordinary cruelty.
I felt sorry for her almost immediately.
That matters enormously.
Carrie only truly works if compassion comes before horror.
If you do not care about her, much of the story loses its power.
This series understands that.
It also updates bullying for an era in which humiliation does not end when you leave school. Social media allows cruelty to be recorded, shared and preserved, turning the actions of a few teenagers into something potentially much larger.
That modernization makes sense.
The original story was always about isolation, shame and collective cruelty. The tools have changed, but people have not changed nearly as much.
Samantha Sloyan also works very well as Margaret White.
Her relationship with Carrie remains one of the most disturbing elements because home, which should offer protection from the outside world, never truly becomes a safe place either.
Between school and home, Carrie seems to have nowhere she can completely relax.
That pressure keeps accumulating.
Mike Flanagan uses the eight-episode format to expand characters and relationships far beyond what a feature film could do. At times that expansion becomes excessive, and some of the teenage subplots interested me considerably less than Carrie herself, but the world generally feels alive.
Most importantly, I never lost my connection with her.
Some scenes are especially painful precisely because we begin to see Carrie feeling accepted.
Whenever she smiles, relaxes or simply behaves like an ordinary teenager, I already find myself worrying about how fragile that happiness is.
Knowledge of the story inevitably changes the experience.
I know what Carrie means.
I know happiness cannot last forever.
That makes apparently joyful moments feel sad before anything has even happened.
The series also understands that teenage cruelty does not always require absolute monsters. Group pressure, resentment, insecurity and the desire to belong can be enough to make people hurt someone else.
That is often more uncomfortable than dividing everyone neatly into heroes and villains.
Visually, the series is polished and dark without attempting to imitate De Palma directly.
I appreciated that.
There would be little point in recreating a film that still works brilliantly fifty years later.
This Carrie wants to become something else.
Longer.
More contemporary.
More focused on modern teenage life.
And more willing to expand its world.
Not every change improves the story for me.
The simplicity of the 1976 film still has enormous power: Carrie, her mother, the school and a tragedy moving relentlessly forward.
Here there are more characters, more plotlines and more ideas competing for attention.
Yet surprisingly, that never bothered me enough to push me away.
Because whenever the series returns its focus to Carrie, it works.
And Summer H. Howell achieves something particularly difficult: for long stretches, I stop constantly thinking about Sissy Spacek.
She does not replace her.
She cannot.
But she creates her own Carrie.
A sweet, innocent and vulnerable girl gradually accumulating pain, disappointment and anger.
That gives the final stretch real emotional force.
The simplest proof that this version worked for me is this:
when the season ended, I did not feel I had already had enough of Carrie.
I wanted Season 2.
Considering how much I love the 1976 film, that was not easy to achieve.
Any new version of Carrie therefore has to compete not only with a story I already know, but with an image of Carrie White that is almost impossible to separate from Sissy Spacek.
That is why I was surprised by how quickly this version drew me in.
Much of the credit goes to Summer H. Howell.
From the beginning, she has an innocence and vulnerability that make it extremely easy to care about Carrie. She does not simply feel “weird” because the story needs an outsider. She feels like a girl who has grown up isolated and badly equipped to deal with a world capable of extraordinary cruelty.
I felt sorry for her almost immediately.
That matters enormously.
Carrie only truly works if compassion comes before horror.
If you do not care about her, much of the story loses its power.
This series understands that.
It also updates bullying for an era in which humiliation does not end when you leave school. Social media allows cruelty to be recorded, shared and preserved, turning the actions of a few teenagers into something potentially much larger.
That modernization makes sense.
The original story was always about isolation, shame and collective cruelty. The tools have changed, but people have not changed nearly as much.
Samantha Sloyan also works very well as Margaret White.
Her relationship with Carrie remains one of the most disturbing elements because home, which should offer protection from the outside world, never truly becomes a safe place either.
Between school and home, Carrie seems to have nowhere she can completely relax.
That pressure keeps accumulating.
Mike Flanagan uses the eight-episode format to expand characters and relationships far beyond what a feature film could do. At times that expansion becomes excessive, and some of the teenage subplots interested me considerably less than Carrie herself, but the world generally feels alive.
Most importantly, I never lost my connection with her.
Some scenes are especially painful precisely because we begin to see Carrie feeling accepted.
Whenever she smiles, relaxes or simply behaves like an ordinary teenager, I already find myself worrying about how fragile that happiness is.
Knowledge of the story inevitably changes the experience.
I know what Carrie means.
I know happiness cannot last forever.
That makes apparently joyful moments feel sad before anything has even happened.
The series also understands that teenage cruelty does not always require absolute monsters. Group pressure, resentment, insecurity and the desire to belong can be enough to make people hurt someone else.
That is often more uncomfortable than dividing everyone neatly into heroes and villains.
Visually, the series is polished and dark without attempting to imitate De Palma directly.
I appreciated that.
There would be little point in recreating a film that still works brilliantly fifty years later.
This Carrie wants to become something else.
Longer.
More contemporary.
More focused on modern teenage life.
And more willing to expand its world.
Not every change improves the story for me.
The simplicity of the 1976 film still has enormous power: Carrie, her mother, the school and a tragedy moving relentlessly forward.
Here there are more characters, more plotlines and more ideas competing for attention.
Yet surprisingly, that never bothered me enough to push me away.
Because whenever the series returns its focus to Carrie, it works.
And Summer H. Howell achieves something particularly difficult: for long stretches, I stop constantly thinking about Sissy Spacek.
She does not replace her.
She cannot.
But she creates her own Carrie.
A sweet, innocent and vulnerable girl gradually accumulating pain, disappointment and anger.
That gives the final stretch real emotional force.
The simplest proof that this version worked for me is this:
when the season ended, I did not feel I had already had enough of Carrie.
I wanted Season 2.
Considering how much I love the 1976 film, that was not easy to achieve.
Mini Review: This adaptation had a major problem before I even started watching it: I love Brian De Palma's 1976 film. Any new version of Carrie therefore has to compete not only with a story I already know, but with an image of Carrie White that is almost impossible to separate from Sissy Spacek. That is why I was surprised by how quickly this version drew me in. Much of the credit goes to Summer H. Howell. From the beginning, she has an innocence and...
More Reviews of Carrie
Watch the Trailer
