Melissa P.
Is a central female character (or in this case, adolescent girl) allowed to follow a path of unconventional sexuality (apart, perhaps, from dabbling in lesbianism)? Mostly she cannot do so without tragic consequences, as exemplified a few years earlier in THE PIANO TEACHER (2001), where of course the critics could let themselves be more accepting, because she’s successful, an intellectual, played by Isabelle Huppert, because the director is understood to be a serious guy, etc. In the case of this film, on the other hand, made before critics had decided that maybe Guadagnino is a serious guy too (but not as serious as Haneke), the reaction seems to have tended towards condemnation and avoidance, in short, not wanting to know. It’s true that the dialogue and performances are variable, but, even if in the end we might say that it’s about “going through a phase”, and as female coming-of-age stories go it can’t at all compare with MARGARET (2011),nevertheless it seems to this viewer that the filmmakers have strived to maintain the courage to explore subject matter that belongs to what is perhaps the most persistent cinematic taboo of all (and maybe increasingly so): female sexuality.
By the way, Criticker predicted that I would assign this a score of 25.
By the way, Criticker predicted that I would assign this a score of 25.
Mini Review: Is a central female character (or in this case, adolescent girl) allowed to follow a path of unconventional sexuality? It’s true that the dialogue and performances are variable, but, even if in the end we might say that it’s about “going through a phase”, nevertheless it seems to this viewer that the filmmakers have strived to maintain the courage to explore subject matter that belongs to what is perhaps the most persistent cinematic taboo of all (and maybe increasingly so): female sexuality.
Watch the Trailer
