Black Swan
A great film that showcases the realm of artistic perfection, and the debilitating effects of an obsession with achieving it. This would work really well as the first part of a triptych alongside Whiplash (2014) and (more recently!) Tar (2022).
29-year old Portman plays a ballerina who is probably in her early twenties and is sheltered to the point that she could be 16 or 17. Portman is fantastic here; she contorts her voice into a breathy thing that is almost a whisper. Her Nina exudes anxiety at every turn.
Three characters around her abuse her to shape and mould her into their desired automaton: her mother, a docile little thing who never leaves her side; her dance instructor, a sensual and lithe being who indulges his darkest whims; and her double, a vanquished and ultimately willing subordinate [there is some debate to be had on whether this is just Nina's psychosis acting out, but I think that even the uncontested scenes like the nightclub sequences bear this out]. I take all three to be equally complicit in Nina's outcome, but it would be interesting to see if others disagree.
Some, including the participants of the film themselves, see some sort of victory encompassed in its dénouement. This sadly isn't the case. A weak girl becomes crushed by expectations, suffers a precipitous decline in mental health and dies in the process. What, at all, can separate victory from defeat if this is the former?
Mini Review: A great film that showcases the realm of artistic perfection, and the debilitating effects of an obsession with achieving it. This would work really well as the first part of a triptych alongside Whiplash (2014) and (more recently!) Tar (2022).
29-year old Portman plays a ballerina who is probably in her early twenties and is sheltered to the point that she could be 16 or 17. Portman is fantastic here; she contorts her voice into a breathy thing that is almost a whisper. Her...
More Reviews of Black Swan
StreetsAJed
I have seen four Darren Aronofsky movies counting this, but I have really only seen one. I don’t mean that literally, of course. But after seeing this, I am convinced he’s only ...
NutronStorm
What a story! This is the PERFECT example for story building. The actual film is literally what happens in the play. That is extraordinary! My favorite scene is when she became ...
floucc
Aronofsky för ihop The Piano Teacher och Perfect Blue och gör det bra! Lägger också fröet för Whiplash. Som Requiem of a Dream har den verkligen Aronofsky-presentation. När musi...
Feraud
Just watched Black Swan for the first time. In short, it had some good elements, but it was neither cool nor cathartic: Convoluted to the very end. Throw everything at the wall ...
See all 5 reviews of Black Swan
Watch the Trailer
