Barbie
Barbie is a fantastically crafted film full of joy, energy, life, heart, and emotion. It does a great job of being entertaining, and is genuinely powerful when it comes to individual questions of identity, meaning, and experience, but falls laughably flat when it comes to systemic ones, ultimately proving to be a very simplistic and individualistic feminist fantasy. But what more could be expected from a Mattel-sponsored film?
The whole film is incredibly entertaining, bursting with life and very funny, with fantastic production design and plenty of powerful and emotional moments. Margot Robbie gives a brilliant performance, bringing real depth and nuance to the character, while Ryan Gosling is phenomenal as Ken, both hilarious and surprisingly emotionally genuine. The direction is strong too, particularly in the way Greta Gerwig balances something that could so easily have been tonally unbearable: corporate IP, camp comedy, feminist satire, existential drama, musical numbers, and a surprisingly sincere meditation on mortality.
Barbie has a particularly powerful arc, learning to accept and embrace the messiness of human life and the impermanence that makes it meaningful. It moved me a lot. The scene where she simply pays attention to the world around her and talks with the old woman is fantastic. Her first real appreciation of human beauty comes not from some grand philosophical revelation, but from stopping to look at another person and recognising the beauty of a life that is temporary and imperfect. The artificiality of Barbieland makes these moments especially effective, because the film gradually introduces genuine human sadness into this impossibly plastic world. The third act contains a few similarly impactful scenes. Ken also has a strong arc, learning to build an identity outside of Barbie.
The film is at its best when dealing with these intimate, human questions. This is where Gerwig’s balancing act really works: beneath all the camp, satire, and corporate absurdity, there is a sincere meditation on what it means to be alive, to construct an identity, and to accept mortality.
And then there’s the gender politics, which are much stronger when focusing on the individual scale than when actually addressing feminism and patriarchy. America Ferrera’s monologue, while certainly hitting you over the head with the film’s message, does capture many of the complexities and difficulties of being a woman. Throughout the film, Gerwig is very good at showing the daily, individual struggles women face.
But its feminist politics become significantly weaker when it tries to explain patriarchy itself. I mean, “Humans make things up like patriarchy to deal with how uncomfortable being human is”? Seriously?? That’s why it was made? I mean come on, that’s more than laughable, that’s flat out moronic. “By giving voice to the cognitive dissonance required to be a woman under patriarchy, you robbed it of its power”? Really? Just being conscious will dismantle patriarchy?
It’s a complete fantasy, and seems to demonstrate an understanding of patriarchy and power as something that exists primarily at the level of individual perception. More fundamentally, the film seems to understand patriarchy primarily as a set of ideas and attitudes rather than as a system of material power. The problem is presented as people believing the wrong things about gender, and consequently the solution seems to be recognising those beliefs and refusing to internalise them.
But patriarchy isn't simply something people collectively imagine into existence. It’s embedded in institutions, social structures, economic relations, cultural norms, and the unequal distribution of power. Becoming conscious of gender roles can certainly be liberating on an individual level, but it doesn't by itself dismantle the structures that produce and reproduce them. The film is much more convincing when showing what patriarchy feels like than when explaining how it actually works.
It also largely ignores other important dimensions of feminism, particularly intersectionality and the relationship between patriarchy, sexism, and capitalism. Everything is framed through gender, while other major divisions, especially class, barely enter the picture. And while the film makes genuine efforts to represent different kinds of women, its conception of womanhood remains fairly universalising. Class, race, sexuality, and other differences that profoundly shape people's experiences of gender are largely secondary to the shared experience of “being a woman.”
The reversal of Barbieland's gender hierarchy is deliberately kept incomplete, I think so that people can reflect on the absurdity of the real-world situation. That's a clever bit of audience manipulation, and probably one of the film's more effective political ideas. But it also reveals how limited the film's imagination of political change is. Its ultimate goal is less to envision a different social order than to make us reflect on the unfairness of the existing one.
So Barbie is at its strongest when it deals with the individual: identity, insecurity, mortality, meaning, and the messy experience of being human. It is much less convincing when it tries to move from those individual experiences to an account of how gendered power actually operates. As a feminist film, it ultimately offers a powerful critique of what patriarchy feels like, but a remarkably simplistic account of what patriarchy is.
Mini Review: Barbie is a fantastically crafted film full of joy, energy, life, heart, and emotion. It does a great job of being entertaining, and is genuinely powerful when it comes to individual questions of identity, meaning, and experience, but falls laughably flat when it comes to systemic ones, ultimately proving to be a very simplistic and individualistic feminist fantasy. But what more could be expected from a Mattel-sponsored film?
The whole film is incredibly entertaining, bursting with life a...
More Reviews of Barbie
halwf
I thought this was fun. Something about it didn’t click with me though. Me and my mum both felt unsatisfied in a way we couldn’t quite pin point. I’ll need to think on it proper...
Janomi
Greta Gerwig transforms one of the world's most recognizable toys into a visually imaginative and surprisingly ambitious film. Barbieland is stunning to look at, with practical ...
Geniasis
Plastic Citations: On the Gender Trouble of Barbie
Greta Gerwig's Barbie arrives wrapped in its own critique, which is either its cleverest gesture or i...
Greta Gerwig's Barbie arrives wrapped in its own critique, which is either its cleverest gesture or i...
See all 4 reviews of Barbie
