First Reformed

nickismydog
Review by
15 Nov 2026
Awesome
97th percentile
100
How do we sustain hope in a world which seems hopeless?  A brilliant, challenging film that asks difficult questions and gives no easy answers. Its themes of environmentalism are strong and something I’ve been thinking about a lot, and it uses that framework to explore much deeper questions. It asks serious questions about faith, the church and its relationship to the environment, institutions, etc. And while faith and hopefulness seem to resolve nothing, despair doesn’t either. But the film isn’t just political, it’s deeply psychological. Toller is a fantastic protagonist and Hawke’s performance is exceptional. There’s despair, grief, loneliness, isolation, self-destruction, etc. There’s a lot to say about the psychology and spirituality in this film, but I’ll just leave it at that.  And the filmmaking is incredible. Very austere, very rigid, very controlled, and the aspect ratio really makes you feel confined and trapped. The sparse music does a great job when it is used. It puts us inside Toller’s mind and makes us experience the world through him, and creates a really strong atmosphere all around.
Mini Review: How do we sustain hope in a world which seems hopeless?  A brilliant, challenging film that asks difficult questions and gives no easy answers. Its themes of environmentalism are strong and something I’ve been thinking about a lot, and it uses that framework to explore much deeper questions. It asks serious questions about faith, the church and its relationship to the environment, institutions, etc. And while faith and hopefulness seem to resolve nothing, despair doesn’t either. But the f...
Watch the Trailer