Schindler's List
Briskly paced, constantly engaging, and very watchable. Visually beautiful and exceptionally well-crafted, with great cinematography, strong blocking, excellent use of colour, and the black-and-white presentation was a great choice.
The story is interesting, and Oskar Schindler is a very interesting protagonist. The performances are great across the board.
Still, the film does filter the Holocaust through a German saviour narrative- the familiar "heroic gentile" trope. But Spielberg is well aware of that I believe, and still does a good job portraying Jewish suffering and individuality. Also, maybe I'm crazy, but I didn't actually find the film all that emotionally moving or impactful.
It treats its subject matter seriously and respectfully overall, although there are a few moments that feel a bit off- slightly insensitive in their attempt to make the film more broadly appealing. The example that stood out most to me was the scene showing the burning of Jewish bodies accompanied by a grand, swelling orchestral score. That felt very off and emotionally manipulative, particularly given the atrocity being depicted. For me, it would have been both more appropriate and more emotionally powerful if it had been presented in silence.
The shower scene also felt questionable, turning a horrific reality endured by millions into something closer to a thriller set piece. Likewise, Schindler's guilt-ridden confession at the end felt overly melodramatic in its execution. And again, I do think the film places too much emphasis on Schindler as a saviour, reinforcing that "heroic gentile" narrative.
Still, I liked it overall, but a few factors held it back for me.
Mini Review: Briskly paced, constantly engaging, and very watchable. Visually beautiful and exceptionally well-crafted, with great cinematography, strong blocking, excellent use of colour, and the black-and-white presentation was a great choice.
The story is interesting, and Oskar Schindler is a very interesting protagonist. The performances are great across the board.
Still, the film does filter the Holocaust through a German saviour narrative- the familiar "heroic gentile" trope. But Spielberg is ...
More Reviews of Schindler's List
StreetsAJed
I'm not sure how to review this, for two reasons. First, how does one analyze a movie based on such horrific, inhuman, real events. This isn't some musician's life story. I don'...
titireviewer
Um filme que não esconde nenhum pouco a realidade cruel do Nazismo, e que ainda hoje tento entender o que realmente aconteceu nesse regime fascista, mas Steven Spielberg traz um...
Knvv1
ممل وطفشت صراحة. والله ما أقول هالجملة بسبب شخصي لكن طويل وبناء بطيء جدًا ممل.
تزامنت مشاهدتي له مع أحداث بالمنطقة، خلّاني أتفكّر وأتابع الأخبار بوعي أكبر بأن الحروب بكل مافي...
decatur555
Some films go beyond cinema, and this is one of them. Schindler’s List does not just tell a story; it becomes memory and testimony. Spielberg approaches the Holocaust with a sen...
See all 5 reviews of Schindler's List
Watch the Trailer
