Star Wars: Episode I - The Phantom Menace
I find it very watchable and entertaining, and definitely has some cool vibes- especially with the lightsabers.
I think Qui-Gon is a great character, especially in his independence from the Council- already offering a form of critique of the Jedi institution early on, and presenting an alternative Light Force user- and I really like Liam Neeson.
However, the film does struggle with attaching to a main protagonist, essentially switching between a handful, and I don’t think its characters are strong or compelling enough to justify that choice. Maul is very cool and fairly intimidating, but very underdeveloped. Palpatine is certainly already interesting, with his machinations behind the scenes.
Overall, I liked the politics, especially in how it briefly covers bureaucracy, corruption, and political paralysis in the face of crisis. It’s very interesting how Palpatine rises to power through manipulation of a crisis.
Of course, the highlight of the film was the Duel of the Fates, a really exciting and fun duel, with an incredible soundtrack and great choreography- although perhaps lacking in emotional stakes and investment.
There was some really good world building, and a few very impressive visuals- Naboo especially looks gorgeous. However, it’s true that visually it’s not outstanding, and perhaps lacks a strong visual identity. The CGI is generally fine, it’s the CGI characters that stand out as bad to me.
Another thing I really appreciate about TPM is its boldness and ambition, it’s definitely something very different.
I think Anakin was one of the weakest elements of the film. Starting the prequels with Anakin as a kid was a bad decision, and as a character he’s not very interesting- and him destroying the Trade Federation ship is certainly something.
The film arguably lacks some cohesive identity and consistency- especially visually, tonally, and thematically.
And overall, the film does admittedly feel a little stiff in a way- a combination of the direction, dialogue, camerawork, visuals, characters, emotion, etc. Individually, the stiffness of each of these factors could exist without much harm, but all combined, they make the film feel a bit stiff in a way.
And of course it’s a very nostalgic and meaningful film to me, which will always affect how I see it.
*reviewing Spence’s fan edit- tightens the pacing, tones dow Jar Jar without removing him, makes Anakin less annoying & more believable, and a few other changes. Lots of small trims that stay “true” to the film while improving it- not changing it completely like some edits try doing
Mini Review: I find it very watchable and entertaining, and definitely has some cool vibes- especially with the lightsabers.
I think Qui-Gon is a great character, especially in his independence from the Council- already offering a form of critique of the Jedi institution early on, and presenting an alternative Light Force user- and I really like Liam Neeson.
However, the film does struggle with attaching to a main protagonist, essentially switching between a handful, and I don’t think its characters...
More Reviews of Star Wars: Episode I - The Phantom Menace
KIDCRITIC1
Watched Star Wars: Episode I – The Phantom Menace this year. This is an awesome star wars movie with Liam Neeson and Ewan Mcgregor. It is about two jedi knights who have to repa...
Malaki2008
Stepping back into a galaxy far, far away over sixteen years after the triumphant conclusion of the original trilogy, George Lucas returned to the director's chair with Star War...
Ritteh
There was a lot of criticism when this came out and I can understand why. The dialogue was often robotic (maybe intentional to match A New Hope?), the acting, especially from th...
See all 4 reviews of Star Wars: Episode I - The Phantom Menace
Watch the Trailer
