1917
This review contains spoilers
Special Effects (VFX) Quality: 1.25/1.5
Because honestly, none of the shots fired at Will actually hit him, which gave me a bit of a "fake" feeling.
Production Design and Costumes: 1/1
Cinematography and Lighting: 1/1
It’s a pity I can’t give it a higher score. It was a true masterpiece of cinematography; the way it felt like there wasn't a single cut from beginning to end, combined with its brilliant editing, produced an extraordinary result. Of course, there were some hidden cuts—like when the camera passes through the thickness of a wall—and I’m actually glad I noticed them.
Directing: 1.9/2
In the sequence where William runs through the wave of battle while soldiers with bayoneted rifles pass by him, I was like: "With all this physical contact between William and the soldiers, how do none of these bayonets even accidentally hit him?" I think a small scratch could have made it feel more natural. But since it wasn't a major issue, I only deducted 0.1.
Screenplay: 1.8/2
If I’m allowed to deduct points for "logic," please consider this; if not, let me know so I don't. I had several questions:
Why didn’t three people go instead of two?
How did Will survive the tunnel collapse debris?
Why didn’t he take even one of the soldiers he met along the way with him? If he had died, 1,600 other people would have died too.
Knowing how much danger he faced toward the end—to the point where he could have been unconscious for hours—if he had just stayed with that group for 10 more kilometers, he might have reached the same goal safer and perhaps even faster.
Will’s luck in reaching the destination so directly via the river... [Note: The sentence seems unfinished in the Persian text].
Acting: 1/1
Extraordinary and flawless.
Sound and Music: 1.5/1.5
Extraordinary and flawless.
Mini Review: This review praises the film's technical mastery, awarding perfect scores to its cinematography, acting, design, and score. Minor deductions in VFX and directing stem from unrealistic near-misses with bullets and bayonets. The screenplay scores 1.8/2 due to logical gaps, such as sending only two men, surviving a tunnel collapse, and questionable travel choices given the massive stakes.
More Reviews of 1917
titireviewer
Emocionante, triste e um show de cores, parabenizo aos envolvidos na maquiagem de ter um trabalho de progressão dos batalhadores de guerra, que fizeram seu máximo para lutar pel...
Lolle04
Kinematografi (19/20)
Virkelig flot filmet! Man kan tydeligt se, at der er kælet for detaljerne. Scenerne i Écoust, hvor alt lys kun kommer fra flammer og nødraketter, er h...
Virkelig flot filmet! Man kan tydeligt se, at der er kælet for detaljerne. Scenerne i Écoust, hvor alt lys kun kommer fra flammer og nødraketter, er h...
Watch the Trailer
