The Departed
This review contains spoilers
Logic and Bug-free Plot: 1/1.5
Although the deaths of both the protagonist and the antagonist—and in a way, leaving the audience without a hero at the end of the film—was a strike against cinematic clichés and a truly commendable audacity, you know, it didn't taste that sweet to my accustomed palate. Also, I wondered why Sullivan, who is willing to kill his father figure or the man who raised him, didn't kill his wife when he found out she was an informant? If he had killed her, he would have ultimately survived. How did his wife find Dignam's number? If DiCaprio knew, why did he trust Sullivan without questioning him? Along with a few other questions and concerns that cross one's mind while watching the movie.
Character Depth: 1.2/1.5
Some roles, like Costello's whore or the new police chief, didn't play a particular part in the execution of the film.
Subtext and Dialogue: 1/1
Acting: 2/2
Narrative Editing: 0/0.5
In some parts of the movie, scenes would appear that had absolutely no relevance to the narrative at that moment, or for instance, their background was unknown. Like the scene where the woman apologized to the man for "last night's incident," even though we hadn't seen anything happen the night before in the story's narrative.
Soundtrack: 0.3/0.5
It was beautiful in some places, but in others, it would abruptly cut off and abruptly start again, or the volume was excessively loud.
Story Innovation: 0.35/0.5
This whole mole/informant story was nothing new, but the fact that both the protagonist and the antagonist get killed was something new.
Mental Longevity (Lasting Impression): 0.35/0.5
Because of the deaths of both the protagonist and the antagonist, I was truly stunned after the movie.
8.2
Although the deaths of both the protagonist and the antagonist—and in a way, leaving the audience without a hero at the end of the film—was a strike against cinematic clichés and a truly commendable audacity, you know, it didn't taste that sweet to my accustomed palate. Also, I wondered why Sullivan, who is willing to kill his father figure or the man who raised him, didn't kill his wife when he found out she was an informant? If he had killed her, he would have ultimately survived. How did his wife find Dignam's number? If DiCaprio knew, why did he trust Sullivan without questioning him? Along with a few other questions and concerns that cross one's mind while watching the movie.
Character Depth: 1.2/1.5
Some roles, like Costello's whore or the new police chief, didn't play a particular part in the execution of the film.
Subtext and Dialogue: 1/1
Acting: 2/2
Narrative Editing: 0/0.5
In some parts of the movie, scenes would appear that had absolutely no relevance to the narrative at that moment, or for instance, their background was unknown. Like the scene where the woman apologized to the man for "last night's incident," even though we hadn't seen anything happen the night before in the story's narrative.
Soundtrack: 0.3/0.5
It was beautiful in some places, but in others, it would abruptly cut off and abruptly start again, or the volume was excessively loud.
Story Innovation: 0.35/0.5
This whole mole/informant story was nothing new, but the fact that both the protagonist and the antagonist get killed was something new.
Mental Longevity (Lasting Impression): 0.35/0.5
Because of the deaths of both the protagonist and the antagonist, I was truly stunned after the movie.
8.2
Mini Review: Review Summary (8.2/10): The Departed features commendable audacity by killing both the protagonist and antagonist, though it left a bitter taste and raised several plot holes regarding Sullivan and DiCaprio's choices. While the acting and dialogue are excellent, the film suffers from narrative editing gaps, inconsistent soundtrack transitions, and irrelevant minor characters.
More Reviews of The Departed
StreetsAJed
I mentioned in my Annie Hall rant that, when my wife and I embarked on our quest to watch every Best Picture winner, there were movies I was dreading for one reason or another. ...
klintworth
I really dislike the concept of the 'guilty pleasure' (if you enjoy art, why should you be ashamed of it? If it's good enough to like then feel free to like it) but The Departed...
Janomi
The Departed is excellent because the cast gives the movie so much energy. Leonardo DiCaprio, Matt Damon, Jack Nicholson, Mark Wahlberg, Martin Sheen, Alec Baldwin, Vera Farmiga...
See all 4 reviews of The Departed
Watch the Trailer
