What We Did That Night (1999) TV Movie

An ex-con (Rick Schroder) returns to town after being released from prison and begins threatening his former college buddies about a frat party hazing incident that they all have tried to hide in their past. (imdb)
Cast and Information
Directed By: Paul Shapiro
Written By: Eric Harlacher
Starring: Tara Reid, Rick Schroder, Jack Noseworthy, Jayce Bartok, Michael Easton, Jennifer Jostyn
Genre: Suspense/Thriller
AKA: Murder at Devil's Glen
Country: USA