Return to Neverland

the-negative-ion
27 Jun 2026
Good
68th percentile
60
It was interesting to see the sequel of a movie about the struggle of moving on from your childhood be about the consequences of moving on from it too quickly. There was a really good idea on display here, especially for a sequel.

Wendy was written very well in this movie. Even though she's moved on from her childhood, she still understands how important it is to have a childhood while you're growing up, which serves as a great contrast for the struggle that the protagonist, Jane, goes through. Deep down, Jane wants to engage with the imagination of the stories of Peter Pan told by her mother, but feels as if she has to reject all of it in order to grow up into a responsible adult. An idea that's further perpetuated by the fact that London is in the middle of a war and the children are being evacuated, pushing her to prepare for the inevitable departure as soon as possible. And the toll that it takes on her as a result is very believable; you see what she goes through and reacts to things that happen around her in a way that makes sense. Expressing a message like this through the lens of a Peter Pan sequel just seemed logical. On the side, I really like that the windows on the house are all taped up to serve as a subtle reminder that there's a war going on, even during the movie's ending.

Of course, there are plenty of things that I wasn't a fan of. I was open to Captain Hook having a new archnemesis after the crocodile had mysteriously departed. But the Octopus was just the crocodile again, but without the history with Hook or even the reason for the ticking. They didn't even seem to really do anything unique with the octopus that they couldn't just do with the crocodile. This was surely a change that didn't need to be made. There were also some instances where some line deliveries and writing choices that just seemed out-of-place in their proper contexts along with Peter and the Lost Boys just being inconsiderate douchebags to Jane (which, thankfully, results in her snapping at them and leaving afterwards). But seeing the way that Jane and the boys progress through the story was done... somewhat well. There were a few hiccups that I thought could've been ironed out. But I do appreciate that Hook's manipulation carried over faithfully from the first movie during his negotiation with Jane.

The slapstick comedy with the Captain was a mixed bag, there were a few charming jokes here and there, and the ending... probably could've been done better. Overall, this was a good sequel. Not great, though, but I would still recommend it. It was the right lesson to teach with the right IP that was unfortunately told at the wrong time.
Mini Review: It was interesting to see the sequel of a movie about the struggle of moving on from your childhood be about the consequences of moving on from it too quickly. There was a really good idea on display here, especially for a sequel.