Starts off OK but gets progressively dumber as it goes along. The witch design was cool though.

Rupert Grint isn't too bad, but Hardwicke can't pull off making any of this scary, not even the witch. I mean, she's kind of cool looking, and may have been put to better use in another story, but not this mushy Lovecraft. Oh, blink and you'll miss Big Fat Greek etcetera's Vardalos

Who could have guessed the director of Twilight wouldn't have the best episode? Seriously, how is it that everything's good so far EXCEPT Lovecraft? And how did that stupid rat thing make the Cats method of CGI look not scary?

Not really scary at all and another one of the series that could've been a bit shorter, but it has its moments, Grint seems to have fun and the witch design is pretty cool.