Had some absolutely classic bits (the Justin Timberlake one was great), but they were outnumbered by the mediocre and flat-out bad ones.

I don't know if it was the magic of entering my teens but I realized that every episode of this show was dated the second it aired and looking at the list of celebrities punk'd is laughable in (insert year that isn't 2005). Their reactions are almost uniformly unfunny and the skits are worse. Oh, since it is largely in-character for me to hate Ashton Kutcher I'll add the following: watching him act shows how bad an actor he is, watching this show illustrates how bad a person he is as well.

A few highlights but really not watchable on a long term basis.

What I got from this is that Ashton Kutcher is an unlikable douche with no comedic talent trying to make us laugh at the expense of other unfunny celebrities. The final result - Something that's completely boring to watch.