Has some of the most hilarious bits of comedy I've ever seen on TV. Best of all, if one bit doesn't make you laugh, another will be along in about 90 seconds.

Good improv is one of the things that impresses me most in this world, because I can't imagine anything more difficult. Somehow the people on this show (in particular Stiles, Brady, and Mochrie) were able to consistently put together outstanding bits every episode. Of course there are misses, but the hit rate is astounding. Also, it gets some extra points retroactively for setting up a fantastic Chappelle's Show episode with Wayne Brady.

As with all improv it has its misses, but at those worst moments its just forgettable. At its best, it had me cracking up. It's for the best they left Carey behind the desk and let the other performers take the stage. Stiles and Mochrie had a chemistry that was always fun to watch and Brady was so great a making up songs on the spot.

I can't deny that nostalgia plays a big role here. It wasn't a perfect show. I mean, in that props game, they sure put objects in front of their crotch like it was their penis an awful lot. However, as improv goes, you can't do much better than these guys, especially Ryan and Colin. My favorite game was always Greatest Hits purely for the passive-aggressive bickering between the two of them. Best moment? Maybe the arctic tern. It was always great when Colin made Ryan lose his shit.

Excellent entertainment value with some very talented comedians. I am not a huge Carey fan but he is a good choice to helm the show and let these folks do what they do best.

Sometimes, this hits the spot. And all the time, it makes me wonder how this got onto network television through the censors.

Some hilarious situations between ryan and colin

The best moments will leave you choking with laughter. The worst moments are usually just boring, and with a fast pace there'll be something more entertaining along soon. I will maintain that having Drew as the host was a great idea, because 1) his laughter is contagious, and 2) he is a huge target for jokes. Colin and Ryan have such great chemistry together, and extract humor from even the most mundane of situations.

Everybody only watches this for Colin and Ryan, 2 truly gifted people who have mastered the art of improv. Drew Carey is mediocre at best as the host and Wayne Brady is just awful most of the time. He's always using his blackness as a crutch or breaking character by laughing and ruining scenes. MEOW!

Has moments of comedy brilliance.

This was fun. Ryan Stiles and Colin Mochrie were especially good.

The funniest things were the funniest things on any show. Still lots of misses.

Anyime Carey himself got up from the desk (usually for those hoedowns) the quality got worse, but the dynamic between Ryan Stiles & Colin Mochrie was consistently great. Really though, the best value of Whose Line was a long term setup for the Wayne Brady skit in Chappelle's Show.