Black Sails is a surprisingly good show. It delivers on the T&A assumed by being on the Starz network, but it also delivers a compelling drama with great characters that are backstabbing, bluffing, and crawling their way to their recognisable forms in either Treasure Island or history. A cross between Pirates of the Caribbean and Game of the Thrones, with comparable production values and a satisfying ending, I highly recommend this show to anyone who isn't squeamish.

The script is decent, the acting is passable, but the production value is unmatched. The sets, costumes and ship battle sequences are unlike anything I've seen on TV before from this time period. Imagine Pirates of the Caribbean, but instead of a story that depends entirely on childish magic & make believe, you've got multi-dimensional characters in a complex power struggle with the British Empire--and made for an 18+ audience. This is truly a refreshing concept for a series.

Might not be historically accurate but great story telling and fun to watch

Starts out strong, towards the end becomes incredibly boresome with annoying characters which you don't care about and which become the focal point of the whole story. Well, to be fair, most of the characters in the series are annoying, but there are few which are completely intolerable.

The revenge power

'Black Sails' tells the real story of the island, the series also functions as a prequel to the fictional story 'Treasure Island', and therefore has fictional pirates - such as Long John Silver and not least the main character Captain Flint - walking side by side with the real ones and series does it in an elegant way. Absolutely the most realistic pirate drama to date, even with the fictional pirates blend in.

The most underrated show ever. All 4 seasons are amazing. The character development is one of the best in television.

A true work of art that touches on what it means to be human. Way beyond just a pirate flic, nothing like Pirates of the Caribbean. The dialogue is some of the best I've ever seen in a show, and the plot beats and storytelling move along mostly expertly with only a few marginal hiccups. Flint is one of the most compelling anti-heroes you'll ever see, and you'll likely change your position on him multiple times.

This show had a way of pulling me in that was hard to describe, because at the start, the story wasn't even all that strong, and there was some cheesiness in the production, but there was something fascinating about it that kept me watching, and I'm glad it did, because the story really ramped up with each season being better than the last. I expect this will stand as the best pirate-themed show for a long time.

Season 1: 73

S01-84 S02-84 S03-87 S04-87 There were no black sails. Some black flags here or there but all the sails were white.

I'm approaching the end of the 1st season. So far, so good. Outstanding production. Everything is more or less meeting the quota. I will say though, and I hate to say it this often: too many good looking people. Pirates were not beautiful. I'm seeing lots of perfect hair and teeth. Silver looks like he's selling Abercrombie. Bones looks like a Wall Street dick. I'd like a more believable cast. I don't need to cum every time I'm entertained.

A soap opera featuring children's-book-pirates and boobs. Come on people, we're better than this aren't we?

I like how clever everyone is, how it relies on illogical or out of charachter moves less than most tv. Becomes much more fun once our man stops fighting for Liberalism and becomes a pirate proper.

Very good series. Polished and grand. Characters are solid.

Toby Stephens was my favorite actor in the RSC. To have him perform in this is amazing. All theater actors should cross over to TV and elevate the art of the TV series. Character development for multiple seasons offers a great canvas for a true performer.

First two seasons - awesome! Third one - not that good, but still very enjoyable. Can't wait for the forth season.

After a somewhat loose first season, this turned out to be a true work a of art. Not only is every shot a treat for the eyes, the score spot on and the production unmatched, the combination of the strong build-up of the story, the great depth of the characters, their bonds and the real-time "psychoanalysis" tirelessly woven into the dialogues with a distinct fine use of language probably makes this the strongest series I have ever come across. As said, this truly is a work of art.

I'm a big fan of the show and it really should get more recognition.

TV: Black Sails was something of a revelation. A piratey adventure show with a solid dramatic rigging and an impressive production budget. The characters were energetically portrayed, the drama and writing was a cut above standard TV fare, and the action set pieces never less than exciting. The second season broached impressive dramatic ground, and the latter two seasons explored the rich mythology/narratology of heroes and villains. Memorable and essential. | S1: 80|S2:81|S3:82|S4:83

Some plots drag a bit and some characters are less engaging, but overall it's a pretty entertaining pirate show, far more of a criminal saga than an adventure saga. Think more Sopranos on the sea, less Pirates of the Caribbean. The epic season 2 finale was pretty cool, reminded me a little of Game of Thrones' Blackwater.